Local phone companies have monopolies on phone service within their ar

Question

Local phone companies have monopolies on phone service within their areas. Cable television can be transmitted via the wires that are already in place and owned by the phone companies. Cable television companies argue that if the telephone companies were to offer cable service, these telephone companies would have an unfair advantage, because their cable transmissions could be subsidized by the profits of their monopolies on phone service.

On the basis of the information provided in the passage above, which of the following questions can be answered?

(A) Are phone companies as efficient as cable companies in providing reliable and inexpensive service?
(B) If phone companies were allowed to provide cable service, would they want to do so?
(C) Do the cable companies believe that the local phone companies make a profit on phone service?
(D) Are local phone companies forbidden to offer cable service?
(E) Is it expected that phone companies will have a monopoly on cable service?

ShankSouljaBoi · Accepted Answer

Great question !!!
Stem of the question is very unique---- We have to look for an answer choice that we can know certainly to be true post reading the argument (Inference)

(A) Are phone companies as efficient as cable companies in providing reliable and inexpensive service?
  No where mentioned in the argument. We cant answer this question with certainty post reading the argument

(B) If phone companies were allowed to provide cable service, would they want to do so?  Irrelevant

(C) Do the cable companies believe that the local phone companies make a profit on phone service?

Yes we can answer this with certainty as the cable companies believe that profits generated from monopoly of the phone companies would be an unfair advantage to phone companies

(D) Are local phone companies forbidden to offer cable service?  We dont know, irrelevant

(E) Is it expected that phone companies will have a monopoly on cable service?  EXPECTATIONS ABOUT FUTURE OR PAST EVENTS ARE NOT INFERENCES

C should cut it

Bunuel · Answer

TWIN QUESTION: https://gmatclub.com/forum/local-phone- ... 26237.html

ouslam · Answer

Since this question resembles the "Must Be true" question type , we take for granted all the information provided in the text, ShankSouljaBoi  already explained the question thoroughly , I will just add a small resume of the information :

"Local phone companies have monopolies" + "they can use the same cable to transmit cable television " = " cable television companies conclude that telephone companies have unfair advantage because  the phone companies already make a profit  in the phone sector "

egmat · Answer

The correct answer is Option C.

Lets first analyze the passage:

- Local phone companies have monopolies on phone service -> they do not have competition as far as providing phone service is concerned
- Cable TV can be transmitted using the same wires already in place for phones (owned by phone companies) -> phone companies have the infra to possibly enter the Cable TV market
- Cable TV companies: 
 > if telephone companies entered the Cable TV market, they would have an unfair advantage
 >  Because  - they can subsidize their cable transmissions by the profits made thanks to the monopolies in phone service (i.e. they can sell cable service at a much cheaper rate, because they will be able to absorb the difference using the profits they made on the phone service)

Lets check the question stem:

On the basis of the information provided in the passage above, which of the following questions can be answered?

In other words, we need to find something that can definitely be inferred from the passage.

Lets check the options:

(A) Are phone companies as efficient as cable companies in providing reliable and inexpensive service?
The passage makes no mention of reliability of service. Hence, this question cannot be answered.

(B) If phone companies were allowed to provide cable service, would they want to do so?
The passage makes no mention about whether phone companies are interested in getting into the cable TV space. Hence, this question cannot be answered.

(C) Do the cable companies believe that the local phone companies make a profit on phone service? 
Definitely correct. 
Cable companies believe that phone companies can subsidize their cable TV offering thanks to the profit they make on phone service => they believe that the phone companies make a profit on phone service.

(D) Are local phone companies forbidden to offer cable service?
The passage makes no mention about whether phone companies are allowed to enter the cable TV space, or forbidden. Hence, this question cannot be answered.

(E) Is it expected that phone companies will have a monopoly on cable service?
Completely out of scope, not discussed anywhere in the passage. All we know is that they have a monopoly in the telephone space - we have no idea if they will have a monopoly on Cable service. Hence, this question cannot be answered.

jaisonsunny77 · Answer

(A) Are phone companies as efficient as cable companies in providing reliable and inexpensive service?  -  the passage does not contain any information regarding the efficiency of phone companies providing cable service.   
(B) If phone companies were allowed to provide cable service, would they want to do so?  -  the passage does not contain any information regarding the preference of the phone company in setting up a cable service.  
(C) Do the cable companies believe that the local phone companies make a profit on phone service? - yes. The cables companies do believe that local phone companies earn a profit from the existing phone services. This school of thought is perfectly reflected in the statement of the passage that reads "...., these telephone companies would have an unfair advantage, because their cable transmissions could be subsidized by the  profits of their monopolies  on phone service." Hence,    (C) is the right answer choice.    
 (D) Are local phone companies forbidden to offer cable service?  -  the passage does not contain any information that could answer this question.   
(E) Is it expected that phone companies will have a monopoly on cable service?  -  what's mentioned in the passage is that  phone companies  have a  monopoly over the phone services  they provide. We do not have any information regarding whether these phone companies would wield monopolistic power over the cable industry as well.

LUBABAYIMER · Answer

C is the correct answer b/c Do the cable companies believe that the local phone companies make a profit on phone service? - yes. The cables companies do believe that local phone companies earn a profit from the existing phone services. This school of thought is perfectly reflected in the statement of the passage that reads "...., these telephone companies would have an unfair advantage, because their cable transmissions could be subsidized by the profits of their monopolies on phone service." Hence, (C) is the right answer

Azakura16 · Answer

Fact: Local phone companies have monopolies on phone services.
Fact: Cable TV can be transmitted via the phone companies’ existing infrastructure.
Fact: Cable companies argue that if the telephone companies also offered cable service, the phone companies would have an unfair advantage, because their TV transmissions could be subsidized by the existing phone monopoly.

A. This can’t be answered. Reliability isn’t mentioned.
B. This can’t be answered. We haven’t heard from the phone companies at all, only the cable companies.
C. This is a yes. If the cable companies think the phone companies will enjoy a subsidy from their phone monopoly, then they must think that the phone monopoly is profitable.
D. This can’t be answered. Though it might seem like a no since the cable companies are getting worked up over it, it’s never actually established.
E. This can’t be answered. Just because they have a monopoly on one thing, that doesn’t guarantee a monopoly on this other thing.
Best answer is C.

saikrishna96 · Answer

Let’s carefully break this down.

The passage states:

* Local **phone companies have monopolies** on phone service in their areas.
* They **own the wires** already in place.
* Cable TV can be transmitted via these wires.
* **Cable companies argue**: if phone companies start offering cable TV, they would have an **unfair advantage**, because the **profits from the phone monopoly** could subsidize cable service.

Now, look at the answer choices:

**(A)** Are phone companies as efficient as cable companies in providing reliable and inexpensive service?
👉 Not answered. Nothing in the passage about efficiency or reliability.

**(B)** If phone companies were allowed to provide cable service, would they want to do so?
👉 Not answered. Passage only says cable companies argue about unfair advantage, not about phone companies’ intentions.

**(C)** Do the cable companies believe that the local phone companies make a profit on phone service?
👉 **Yes, this is supported.** The argument of "unfair advantage" depends on the assumption that phone companies are making profits from their monopoly. Otherwise, no subsidies would be possible.

**(D)** Are local phone companies forbidden to offer cable service?
👉 Not answered. Passage doesn’t mention any legal prohibition.

**(E)** Is it expected that phone companies will have a monopoly on cable service?
👉 Not answered. Passage only talks about unfair advantage, not about future monopoly expectations.

✅ **Correct Answer: (C)**

Local phone companies have monopolies on phone service within their ar

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

GMAT Critical Reasoning (CR) Questions

Local phone companies have monopolies on phone service within their ar

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia