Profile Eval: 680 GMAT, 3.1 GPA, Non-traditional applicant

Hi Accepted(dot)com,

This is a copy of my post in the peer review forum but I'd love to get your input as well. Here it is:

Demographics: 22, Male, Canadian
GMAT: 680, 45Q, 38V, 6.0 AWA, 8 IR

Education:

• BBA, General Management, 3.1 GPA from relatively obscure public US university, received minor student award
• Graduate Certificate in Applied Statistics, Penn State (starting Jan 2013, may upgrade to Masters post-MBA)

Work Experience:

• Worked full-time during both high school and university
• 3 years in an administrative position for a professional sports team, finalist for an industry award for Best Administrative Services
• 2 years working for government contractor in Canada in public safety, promoted to supervise 25-40 employees after 1 year, elected union steward representing 450 union members
• 1 year of freelance work doing some consumer goods purchasing at Asian trade fairs for North American retail companies (honestly I felt like I was puttering around... but I obviously won't write that)
• Current (just started): Working in government HR department in a communications role

Extracurriculars: ~7 weeks of political volunteering in the past, ~2 years of involvement as a trade union advocate both inside and outside the workplace. Delivered speeches to over 300 people which were very well-received

Career goals: Social enterprise, because of my strong belief in public service and my personal background

Schools:

• "Dream schools": Kellogg, Haas, Johnson, Yale
• Already applied to: Johnson, Stern
• Probably applying to: Kelley, Kellogg, Fuqua
• Also considering: Ross, Goizueta, Kenan-Flagler, Tepper, McDonough, McCombs
• Preferred Location: Prefer US NE, also happy with Midwest, California or Mid-Atlantic, prefer not SE or Texas (except Austin)

Uniqueness:

• Worked full time while studying full time, finished undergrad degree in 4 years
• First-generation immigrant (to Canada) and first-generation university graduate
• Holds commercial pilot licence, 300 hours in light aircraft
• Was a key figure in repairing the employer-union relationship as a union steward and subsequently negotiated the best collective agreement of its kind in Canada, averting a crippling strike

International Experience:

• Lived in Korea, Canada, US and Taiwan
• Native-level English, intermediate levels of proficiency in Chinese, Korean and French
• Travelled to over 15 different countries in last 2 years, particularly keen on emerging markets

Recommenders ("pool" of people who agreed to write for me):

• Just started current job so cannot use current manager as a recommender
• Former college statistics instructor (taught me for one semester, got A+)
• Former manager and also actually former flight instructor (strange coincidence, he is a business guy who wanted to fly so he did that for a bit), knows me very well as a person and employee
• Former trade union executive who worked closely with me during negotiations and union meetings
• Former co-worker who worked in another department but knows me well
• Former co-worker who is currently a federal police officer

Other:

• Taking a maths and computer programming course p/t from local university to improve quantitative side of application (although I do have more quantitative aptitude than my GMAT would suggest)
• Also taking stats certificate from Penn State partly to show my commitment to proving my quantitative ability
• Considering retaking GMAT

Sorry for the unwieldy length but I tried to organise everything so it was easy to read. I would like to know peoples' thoughts mainly on my admissions chances and which schools I should target. I have been reassured in the past that I can think about many of those schools on my list but my non-traditional background makes me a little unsure of myself for things like this. I plan to apply to 6-8 schools, so I'd like to compile a list of maybe 1-2 "reach" schools, 3-4 target schools and 2-3 safety schools. Thanks for your help!