Brian123 wrote:
I have the same question. When I see the phrase "Just like" I do not think that the 2 entities are alike in all aspects. Of course a human hut and a bird's nest can never be alike in all aspects. The idea of "Just like" or even "Not unlike" is it to compare 2 entities and then introduce the factors that are common to both. What is the point of introducing 3 factors that are common to nests and huts and then suddenly introducing a factor that is not common.
AndrewN, would you mind sharing your thoughts?
Like many people, according to the question statistics, I was able to narrow the options down to (B) and (D) fairly quickly, and then I started considering the possible difference in meaning between them. The comparison
like, on its own, suggests a similarity between different entities.
Just like is an extension of that thought, suggesting a higher degree of similarity than
like on its own. That said, I agree that
just like does not mean
identical all around. I could write,
Just like the leg muscles of a human, those of the cheetah contain many fast-twitch fibers that allow the creature to generate high speeds. The emphasis seems to be on a shared trait of muscle composition, fast-twitch fibers. Whether the
that clause that follows is meant to reach back to the human is more debatable, given what the clause says. Are humans fast? That seems like a judgment call. Do I think the comparison suggests that a human can generate high speeds? Yes, I do, but I would call it a secondary concern.
All of this is to say that after ten or so more seconds of deliberation between (B) and (D), I chose (D) as the safer option.
Not unlike allows for a little more wiggle room within the comparison than
just like. Believe it or not, I started thinking of different types of mud that might be used for bird nests in different areas, and I started to think that
just like seemed too narrow. I teach my students this all the time, but when in doubt, play it safe. Do not chase what you think may sound better. The less restrictive comparison between birds and humans is more fitting here, particularly in light of the tools that are mentioned in the final part of the sentence.
I hope that helps. Thank you for bringing the question to my attention.
- Andrew