HKD1710
Various forms of plant and animal life have longer life spans than Homo Sapiens (e.g., Galapagos turtles, sequoia trees). While scientists do not live long enough to study the complete life-cycle of these life forms, the development of a single individual can be inferred by observing many specimens at various stages. The same principle can be applied to astronomy or geology. Scientists can learn about the evolution of deserts and rock formations by observing various specimens.
What assumption can be made about the passage?
A) Methods of observation are the same for most subjects.
B) Redwood trees and other endangered species need to be studied more before they become extinct.
C) There are many methods of approaching scientific material which lead to a wide variety of conclusions.
D) Examples of various stages of development are available to scientists for observation and study.
E) There are many material features in our environment which are not observable or measurable by today's methods
Source: 800Score
first,by
e-gmat Assumption Must
1. Provide new information
2. be true (and pass the negation test)
3. Support the Conclusion
The argument states:
Premise: Various forms of plant and animal life have longer life spans than Homo Sapiens (e.g., Galapagos turtles, sequoia trees)
Premise: While scientists do not live long enough to study the complete life-cycle of these life forms
Premise: the development of a single individual can be inferred by observing many specimens at various stages
Conclusion: The same principle can be applied to astronomy or geology. Scientists can learn about the evolution of deserts and rock formations by observing various specimens.
the coclusion here is that the principle of observing many specimens at various stages
can be applied to astronomy or geologyLets Prethink:
we need to show that we are able to apply the principle for both (animals and plants) and (astronomy or geology)
Weakener: what if we are not able to apply the observations method on other topics
except animals and plants..
Prethinked Assumption: We are able to perform observations in astronomy or geology
A) Methods of observation are the same for most subjects.
so what? it doesn't have to be the same method.. WRONG
B) Redwood trees and other endangered species need to be studied more before they become extinct.
doensn't support the conclusion
C) There are many methods of approaching scientific material which lead to a wide variety of conclusions.
doensn't support the conclusion
D) Examples of various stages of development are available to scientists for observation and study.
Bingo just like our prethinking
lets apply the negation test:
Examples of various stages of development are NOT available to scientists for observation and study.
if they are not available - so the study is inapplicable - and the arguments breaks down.E) There are many material features in our environment which are not observable or measurable by today's methods
So - how does it help us? Out of scope