Thank you for using the timer - this advanced tool can estimate your performance and suggest more practice questions. We have subscribed you to Daily Prep Questions via email.
Customized for You
we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History
Track Your Progress
every week, we’ll send you an estimated GMAT score based on your performance
Practice Pays
we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History
Not interested in getting valuable practice questions and articles delivered to your email? No problem, unsubscribe here.
Thank you for using the timer!
We noticed you are actually not timing your practice. Click the START button first next time you use the timer.
There are many benefits to timing your practice, including:
Mark your calendars - All GMAT Club Tests are free and open November 22nd to celebrate Thanksgiving Day! Access will be available from 0:01 AM to 11:59 PM, Pacific Time (USA)
At the beginning of the day, a pet store had dogs and cats in the rati
[#permalink]
Show Tags
08 Jul 2017, 04:25
1
00:00
A
B
C
D
E
Difficulty:
55% (hard)
Question Stats:
56% (01:11) correct 44% (01:07) wrong based on 200 sessions
HideShow timer Statistics
At the beginning of the day, a pet store had dogs and cats in the ratio of 5 to 3. If no new animals were added to the store and the only animals that left were those that were sold, what was the ratio of dogs to cats at the end of the day?
At the beginning of the day, a pet store had dogs and cats in the rati
[#permalink]
Show Tags
08 Jul 2017, 04:33
Bunuel wrote:
At the beginning of the day, a pet store had dogs and cats in the ratio of 5 to 3. If no new animals were added to the store and the only animals that left were those that were sold, what was the ratio of dogs to cats at the end of the day?
(1) The store sold 2 dogs that day.
(2) The store sold 1/3 of its cats that day.
We are looking at a ratio. So it could be any numbers in that ratio. For getting new ratio, most of the time it requires some numeric value to it or change in ratio for both .
Let's see the statements
1) store sold 2 dogs that day. But we do not the numeric values of dog and cat or the ratios Insuff 2)store sold 1/3 cats. Again no numeric value for both and no info on change in ratio of dog Insufficient
Combined.. Nothing much on NUMERIC value.. Ratio is 5x-2:2x.... Insuff
At the beginning of the day, a pet store had dogs and cats in the rati
[#permalink]
Show Tags
08 Jul 2017, 09:27
Bunuel wrote:
At the beginning of the day, a pet store had dogs and cats in the ratio of 5 to 3. If no new animals were added to the store and the only animals that left were those that were sold, what was the ratio of dogs to cats at the end of the day?
(1) The store sold 2 dogs that day.
(2) The store sold 1/3 of its cats that day.
If no new animals were added to the store and the only animals that left were those that were sold, what was the ratio of dogs to cats at the end of the day?
This sentence is a little confusing, but shouldn't it be the following. "The only animals that were left were those that were NOT sold?"
With regards to the question.
Old Ratio D:C = 5:3 => D = 5x and C = 3x
New Ratio D:C =?
1) 2 dogs sold that day If x = 1, then D = 5 and C = 3 2 dogs sold, so the new ratio D : C = 3 : 3 If x = 2, then D = 10 and C = 6 2 dogs sold, so the new ratio D : C = 8 : 6
Inconsistent answers. Insufficient.
2) (1/3) of total cats were sold. If x = 1, then D = 5 and C = 3 (1/3) of 3 = 1, so the new ratio D : C = 5 : 2 If x = 2, then D = 10 and C = 6 (1/3) of 6 = 2, so the new ratio D : C = 10 : 4 If x = 3, then D = 15 and C = 9 (1/3) of 9 = 3, so the new ratio D : C = 15 : 6
This is keeping the number of dogs constant. If even 1 dog is sold, the ratio changes. Insufficient.
(1 + 2) Same above. x= 1 ; D = 5 , C = 3 New Ratio = 3:2
At the beginning of the day, a pet store had dogs and cats in the rati
[#permalink]
Show Tags
09 Jul 2017, 18:41
At the beginning of the day: number of dogs/number of cats = 5x/3x (x is a positive integer)
(1) The store sold 2 dogs that day.
--> At the end of the day: dogs/cats = (5x-2)/3x
Depending on particular values of x, we will get different ratios. For example: x = 1 --> dogs/cats = 3/3 x = 2 --> dogs/cats = 8/6 Inconsistent answer => Insufficient statement
ELIMINATE (A) and (D). KEEP (B), (C) and (E)
(2) The store sold 1/3 of its cats that day.
--> The number of cats sold: (1/3)3x = x --> At the end of the day: dogs/cats = 5x/(3x-x) = 5x/2x = 5/2 For whatever values of x, we always get sufficient answers => Sufficient statement
Re: At the beginning of the day, a pet store had dogs and cats in the rati
[#permalink]
Show Tags
09 Jul 2017, 20:33
1
Lucy Phuong wrote:
At the beginning of the day: number of dogs/number of cats = 5x/3x (x is a positive integer)
(1) The store sold 2 dogs that day.
--> At the end of the day: dogs/cats = (5x-2)/3x
Depending on particular values of x, we will get different ratios. For example: x = 1 --> dogs/cats = 3/3 x = 2 --> dogs/cats = 8/6 Inconsistent answer => Insufficient statement
ELIMINATE (A) and (D). KEEP (B), (C) and (E)
(2) The store sold 1/3 of its cats that day.
--> The number of cats sold: (1/3)3x = x --> At the end of the day: dogs/cats = 5x/(3x-x) = 5x/2x = 5/2 For whatever values of x, we always get sufficient answers => Sufficient statement
(B) IS CORRECT!
Hi. In statement 2 there is no information regarding number of dogs sold... So B is insufficient. I think E should be answer. Correct me if I am wrong.
Re: At the beginning of the day, a pet store had dogs and cats in the rati
[#permalink]
Show Tags
09 Jul 2017, 21:42
kedarsharma wrote:
Lucy Phuong wrote:
At the beginning of the day: number of dogs/number of cats = 5x/3x (x is a positive integer)
(1) The store sold 2 dogs that day.
--> At the end of the day: dogs/cats = (5x-2)/3x
Depending on particular values of x, we will get different ratios. For example: x = 1 --> dogs/cats = 3/3 x = 2 --> dogs/cats = 8/6 Inconsistent answer => Insufficient statement
ELIMINATE (A) and (D). KEEP (B), (C) and (E)
(2) The store sold 1/3 of its cats that day.
--> The number of cats sold: (1/3)3x = x --> At the end of the day: dogs/cats = 5x/(3x-x) = 5x/2x = 5/2 For whatever values of x, we always get sufficient answers => Sufficient statement
(B) IS CORRECT!
Hi. In statement 2 there is no information regarding number of dogs sold... So B is insufficient. I think E should be answer. Correct me if I am wrong.
Hi,
IMHO, your doubt could be justified to some extend. I will be inclined towards your line of thoughts IF the statement is written this way "2 dogs are sold that day". Reading that sentence, I will definitely question - how about cats? Is there any cat sold?
However, if the statement says "The store sold 2 dogs and no cats that day", I'll find the added "and no cats" unnecessary. That's why even when I reread the question, I still choose to think the same way as I did in my previous post.
Having said that, I think we shouldn't worry about this much because this question doesn't seems to be a GMAT-like one. Unless you are totally fresh in GMAT and have just practiced very few official question, you may agree with me that you've never ever faced the same issue, right?
Re: At the beginning of the day, a pet store had dogs and cats in the rati
[#permalink]
Show Tags
09 Jul 2017, 22:42
1
Lucy Phuong wrote:
At the beginning of the day: number of dogs/number of cats = 5x/3x (x is a positive integer)
(1) The store sold 2 dogs that day.
--> At the end of the day: dogs/cats = (5x-2)/3x
Depending on particular values of x, we will get different ratios. For example: x = 1 --> dogs/cats = 3/3 x = 2 --> dogs/cats = 8/6 Inconsistent answer => Insufficient statement
ELIMINATE (A) and (D). KEEP (B), (C) and (E)
(2) The store sold 1/3 of its cats that day.
--> The number of cats sold: (1/3)3x = x --> At the end of the day: dogs/cats = 5x/(3x-x) = 5x/2x = 5/2 For whatever values of x, we always get sufficient answers => Sufficient statement
(B) IS CORRECT!
Lucy first of All statement B only tells us about cats and no other information about dogs so yes this information is incomplete Taking together two statements, one cant find the right answer why? because everything depends on the value of x and when x changes, the value of ratio changes we have 5x/3x initially statement 1 says that 2 dogs were sold so 5x will become 5x-2 statement 2 says 1/3 cats were sold so we can write this as 1/3(3x) = x now combine the above two and u will get 5x-2/x-----> whenever u will change the value of x, you will get a new ratio
_________________
Push yourself again and again. Don't give an inch until the final buzzer sounds. -Larry Bird Success isn't something that just happens - success is learned, success is practiced and then it is shared. -Sparky Anderson -S
At the beginning of the day, a pet store had dogs and cats in the rati
[#permalink]
Show Tags
10 Jul 2017, 01:23
sananoor wrote:
Lucy first of All statement B only tells us about cats and no other information about dogs so yes this information is incomplete Taking together two statements, one cant find the right answer why? because everything depends on the value of x and when x changes, the value of ratio changes we have 5x/3x initially statement 1 says that 2 dogs were sold so 5x will become 5x-2 statement 2 says 1/3 cats were sold so we can write this as 1/3(3x) = x now combine the above two and u will get 5x-2/x-----> whenever u will change the value of x, you will get a new ratio
Hi saranoor,
Thanks for your response.
As I said in my latest post, I understand why (E) could be the answer. The key point leading to different answers lies on different ways of interpretation of the provided statements. If the statement is written the other way as I suggested above, I will definitely mark choice (E). Please read my previous post responding to another one for more information. Thanks.
It's all about my personal thought. I could be right, I could be wrong also. At the end of the day, this question is, to me, not like a GMAT question, and as expert GMATNinja advised, let's spend our precious time discussing official questions instead.
If OA is E, I will take the experience and move on.
p/s: I remember we talked on chat box yesterday... thanks for your interesting questions... will join again when I have time
Here's a hint so that you can reattempt this question on your own: based on the given information, the STARTING ratio of dogs to cats was 5:3. This means that the initial number of dogs MUST be a multiple of 5 and the initial number of cats MUST be an equivalent multiple of 3. For example:
5 dogs and 3 cats 10 dogs and 6 cats 15 dogs and 9 cats Etc.
Based on the information in the two Facts, with the answer to this question change based on the starting number of animals, or will it stay the same?
At the beginning of the day, a pet store had dogs and cats in the
[#permalink]
Show Tags
06 Jun 2018, 10:32
pranayeekarmakar wrote:
At the beginning of the day, a pet store had dogs and cats in the ratio of 5 to 3. If no new animals were added to the store and the only animals that left were those that were sold, what was the ratio of dogs to cats at the end of the day?
(1) The store sold 2 dogs that day.
(2) The store sold \(\frac{1}{3}\) of its cats that day.
From the question stem, we are able to figure out that for every 5x dogs, we will have 3x cats.
1. This statement has no information about the cats. A total of 2 dogs are sold (Insufficient)
2. This statement has no information about the dogs We are told that \(\frac{1}{3}\)rd of the dogs are sold. In the end, we would be left have \(\frac{2}{3}*3x = 2x\) dogs. (Insufficient)
When we combine the information present in both the statements, we can't arrive at a unique ratio of the cats and dogs at the end of the day(after the cats and dogs are sold because we don't know the initial number of cats and dogs in the store (Insufficient - Option E)
P.S Have moved your question to the appropriate forum. These are the RULES which you need to follow while posting questions.
_________________
You've got what it takes, but it will take everything you've got
Re: At the beginning of the day, a pet store had dogs and cats in the rati
[#permalink]
Show Tags
08 Jun 2018, 01:27
pranayeekarmakar wrote:
At the beginning of the day, a pet store had dogs and cats in the ratio of 5 to 3. If no new animals were added to the store and the only animals that left were those that were sold, what was the ratio of dogs to cats at the end of the day?
(1) The store sold 2 dogs that day.
(2) The store sold \(\frac{1}{3}\) of its cats that day.
Re: At the beginning of the day, a pet store had dogs and cats in the rati
[#permalink]
Show Tags
12 Oct 2018, 11:02
chetan2u wrote:
Bunuel wrote:
At the beginning of the day, a pet store had dogs and cats in the ratio of 5 to 3. If no new animals were added to the store and the only animals that left were those that were sold, what was the ratio of dogs to cats at the end of the day?
(1) The store sold 2 dogs that day.
(2) The store sold 1/3 of its cats that day.
We are looking at a ratio. So it could be any numbers in that ratio. For getting new ratio, most of the time it requires some numeric value to it.
Let's see the statements
1) store sold 2 dogs that day. But we do not the numeric values of dog and cat Insuff 2)store sold 1/3 cats. Again no numeric value Insufficient
Combined.. Nothing much on NUMERIC value.. Ratio is 5x-2:2x.... Insuff
E
The problem with (2) is not that it does not give a numerical value, remember that it is a ratio, the problem is that it does not give you any info about the dogs, if dogs were to remain constant this statement would be sufficient...
As per the second statement, 1/3 of the cats were sold. So remaining cats should be 2/3. Now it is given that number of cats were 3x. So 2x cats remained at the end of the days. And since no dogs were sold, So dogs should be 5x.
As per the second statement, 1/3 of the cats were sold. So remaining cats should be 2/3. Now it is given that number of cats were 3x. So 2x cats remained at the end of the days. And since no dogs were sold, So dogs should be 5x.
So the ratio should be 5x:2x. Sufficient.
Please let me know where I am going wrong.
We do not know anything about number of dogs sold..
_________________
close
56% (01:11) correct 
