Smiti25
GMATNinja Can we get an explanation for this passage OAs? It would be of great help.
Thanks.
Hi Smiti
I understand you have asked for expert help and i am not one but just trying to help.
First lets get these facts straight
1) There is an animal by name Ant-eater (because it eats ants or whatever!)
2) It has two kinds of sensory's organs that can locate prey
3) the researches have identified them as electroreceptors and tactile receptors.
4) electroreceptors respond even to smallest of electrical fields where as tactile receptors respond to really strong electrical fields (like 1000 times greater that what electroreceptors respond to)
Now lets approach the questions
1. According to the passage, which of the following is a characteristic that distinguishes electroreceptors from tactile receptors?
(A) The manner in which electroreceptors respond to electrical stimuli
its mentioned they respond to weak electrical signals but this dos not gives us the difference between the two receptors.(B) The tendency of electroreceptors to be found in clusters
the passage merely mentions that electroreceptors but the passage does not say anything about how tactile receptors exist.So we cannot really comment on this and cannot identify any difference with 100% surity.(C) The unusual locations in which electroreceptors are found in most species.
The passage mentions that both the receptors are found on the anteater's snout. So this is infact a similarity between the two receptors.(D) The amount of electrical stimulation required to excite electroreceptorsThe only difference between electroreceptors from tactile receptors that the author is pointing out is at the amount of electric simulation they respond to. In the passage the author mentions that while electroreceptors respond to "extremely weak electrical fields", the tactile receptors (also present on the anteater’s snout) responds to electrical field strengths about 1,000 times greater that those known to excite electroreceptors.(E) The amount of nervous activity transmitted to the brain by electroreceptors when they are excited
The passage just mentions that there is only recording of the transmission of nervous activity to the brain. No mention of the amount of nervous activity that is transmitted. Hence no basis for any comparison.2. Which of the following can be inferred about the experiment described in the first paragraph?
(A) Researchers had difficulty verifying the existence of electroreceptors in the anteater because electroreceptors respond to such a narrow range of electrical field strengths.
The passage did not mention about any difficulties that the researchers might have faced in verifying the existence of the anteaters. (B) Researchers found that the level of nervous activity in the anteater’s brain increased dramatically as the strength of the electrical stimulus was increased.
No mention of this either. In the first paragraph the passage just says that the anteater's snout has some electroreceptors that respond to weak electrical fields and there are some tactile receptors on its snout that respond to extremely strong electrical fields.(C) Researchers found that some areas of the anteater’s snout were not sensitive to a weak electrical stimulus.
Yep! exactly how we summarized the first para in option B above. (D) Researchers found that the anteater’s tactile receptors were more easily excited by a strong electrical stimulus than were the electroreceptors.
The passage mentions that tactile receptors respond to strong electrical fields (about 1,000 times greater than those known to excite electroreceptors. However, the passage doesn't say that it responds easily or more easily. These tactile receptors just respond to strong electrical fields. Thats it! (E) Researchers tested small areas of the anteater’s snout in order to ensure that only electroreceptors were responding to the stimulus.
The passage says "The researchers made this discovery by exposing small areas of the snout to extremely weak electrical fields". Here the passage does not details out about how the researches have conducted the experiment.3. The author of the passage most probably discusses the function of tactile receptors (lines 7-11) [While it is true that tactile receptors, another kind of sensory organ on the anteater’s snout, can also respond to electrical stimuli, such receptors do so only in response to electrical field strengths about 1,000 times greater than those known to excite electroreceptors.] in order to
(A)
eliminate an alternative explanation of anteaters’ response to electrical stimuli.This is our answer. See if he had merely known that anteater has two kinds of sensory organs and both respond to electrical field then it could have been possible that when researchers were applying electrical fields to stimulate electroreceptors may be tactile receptors were responding. In that case the research would be rendered useless. By mentioning the fact that these tactile receptors need 1000 times greater electrical field than what electroreceptors need to respond the author has eliminated the possibility we mentioned above. This information about tactile receptors ensures us that it is indeed the electroreceptors that are responding and not the tactile ones.(B) highlight a type of sensory organ that has a function identical to that of electroreceptors
The passage does not mention any of the functions of tactile receptors. So this is irrelevant. (C) point out a serious complication in the research on electroreceptors in anteaters.
What sort of complication?? the passage doesn't mention any and if we are talking about response to electrical fields then that just cannot be a complication because electroreceptors respond to very weak electrical fields and tactile one's to very strong electrical fields and in order to identify electroreceptors the researchers exposed small areas of the snout to extremely weak electrical fields.(D) suggest that tactile receptors assist electroreceptors in the detection of electrical signals.
tactile receptors respond to electrical stimuli that is 1000 times greater than those known to excite electroreceptors. Cant see how tactile receptors can help electroreceptors. (E) introduce a factor that was not addressed in the research on electroreceptors in anteaters.
Cant see how this can be the answer. If the author is introducing any information it has a purpose.I have explained only 3 answers. If you need help with other 3 also let me know. Happy to help