From the letters in MAGOOSH, we are going to make three-letter "words.

Why cant we write it as 7P3/2!, dividing by 2! for two O's

There are 6 different letters with repetition of one letter, i.e. O.

Let the 3-letter words have all the letters different.

When all the letters are different, the 3 letters can be selected in 6C3 ways. Since the letters can arrange among themselves in 3! ways,

The number of ways to select 3 letters out of 6 = 6C3*3! = 120

When one letter is repeated, two out of the three letters will be O. The last letter can be selected in 5 ways and the letters can arrange themselves in 3!/2! = 3 ways.

Thus, the number of 3-letter words with the repetition of O = 5*3 = 15

Thus, total letters = 120+15 = 135

Thus, the correct option is A.

I am confused a bit. why we can't consider 7 letters from the beginning and arrange them? I mean 7*6*5 = 210?

Thank you! That makes sense!

Posted from my mobile device

Hello. Did you get any answer on this? Because I was thinking the same. Why can't we solve this question by 7P3/2!?

That's alright, I understand this solution. But my question is, why can't this be solved by 7P3/2!? What is the flaw in this strategy? Since we are choosing 3 letters from 7 letters, using permutation because order matters, and dividing the result by 2! because one letter repeats twice.

You divide by 2! when all the solutions have repetitions but is it so here in all cases. NO

If the letter is MAG, then there is no repetition. So you are subtracting more cases than you should by dividing everything by 2!.

What if we want to move fwd on 7*6*5 or 210 cases.

There are two types of repetition.

1) When the word contains exactly one O.
The other two can be chosen in 5C2 or 10 ways. But each way can be arranged in 3! ways.
Thus, total 10*3! Or 60 ways.

2) When the word contains 2 Os.
The other one can be chosen in 5C1 or 5 ways. But each way can be arranged in 3!/2! ways.
Thus, total 5*3!/2! Or 15 ways.

Ways that are repeated 60+15 or 75 ways.


Total = 210-75 = 135 ways

Hope it helps

Oh I see. Yeah yeah, I understand it now. Thank you so much for pointing my mistake! It's a big help

Hello from the GMAT Club BumpBot!

Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up - doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos).

Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.