namita_am wrote:
mikemcgarry can you please answer this question, also it will be great if you could explain option-wise.
Dear
namita_am,
I'm happy to respond.
Here's the question again:
Many Lithuanian words preserve important features of words in Proto-Indo-European, the language from which it is descended, and scholars accordingly compare them to the corresponding words in other Indo-European languages in order to reconstruct the original Proto-Indo-European forms.
A. it is descended, and scholars accordingly compare them to the corresponding words in other Indo-European languages
B. Lithuanian descends, and scholars accordingly compare it to the corresponding words in another Indo-European language
C. Lithuanian is descended, and scholars accordingly compare Lithuanian words to the corresponding words in other Indo-European languages
D. they descend, and scholars accordingly compare them to the corresponding word in another Indo-European language
E. there is descent, and scholars accordingly compare Lithuanian words to the corresponding words in other Indo-European languagesThis question is
throwing a curveball that I am not sure whether the real GMAT would throw.
You see, exactly what has "
descended" from "
Proto-Indo-European"? It's not the individual Lithuanian words, but instead, the
Lithuanian language. One language descends from another. I don't know whether the GMAT would expect a student to recognize this particular fact, but recognizing it is crucial for answering the question.
Only options (B) & (C) get this part correct: these two choices specify that it is the language itself, not the individual words previously mentioned, that descend from "
Proto-Indo-European."
Option (B) gets this correct, but then illogically suggest that folks compare "
it" (the Lithuanian language) to individual words in
Proto-Indo-European." This is illogical and incorrect.
The only possible answer is (C).
I'm not a huge fan of this question. The end of the answer choices, from the word "
to" onward, are identical except for (D), which has an illogical difference. I think the question would be tighter if (D) were changed to resemble the other answers, so that the underlined segment would be shorter.
Here's a high quality GMAT SC practice question:
Popular ImaginationDoes this make sense?
Mike