guerrero25 wrote:
Mr. Arlekino: Burat Company, which ordered a large lot of bolts from our company, requested that we use SP23 to manufacture those bolts, because SP23 is more efficient and produces bolts of higher quality than most of the other bolt-producing machines. Our only SP23 is currently broken and will not be fixed for three days, and the deadline for completing the order cannot be moved. Therefore, we will be forced to disregard Burat’s request and use our SP20 machine, which is less efficient but is in working condition, allowing us to meet the deadline.
The argument above assumes which of the following?
(A)No other bolt producing machine is more effective and produces bolts of higher quality than SP23.
(B)By the time SP23 is repaired, SP20 will have completed the order.
(C)The quality of bolts produced by SP20 is higher than the quality of bolts produced by SP23.
(D)For any currently available bolt-producing machine other than SP20, it would be impossible to complete the order on time.
(E)Time saved during production of bolts by the more efficient SP23 would not be sufficient to compensate for the three days lost to its repair.
OA to follow ..
IMO E
CONCLUSION:we will be forced to disregard Burat’s request and use our SP20 machine
PREMISE: Our only SP23 is currently broken and will not be fixed for three days, and the deadline for completing the order cannot be moved.
clearly this is
assuming that if we wait FOR SP 23 to get repaired and then start production ..then remaining time will be insufficient to meet the deadline.==>that is why they are concluding that they are forced to use SP20 to meet that deadline.
THIS IS CLEARLY STATED IN OPTION E: Time saved during production of bolts by the more efficient SP23 would not be sufficient to compensate for the three days lost to its repair.
HENCE
EOTHER OPTIONS:(A)No other bolt producing machine is more effective and produces bolts of higher quality than SP23.
WRONG.OUT OF SCOPE.
(B)By the time SP23 is repaired, SP20 will have completed the order.
WRONG.this was little tempting ....but still if have not completed the order but this will not allow us to use only SP23 only as we are lacking time for time deadline and it is not stated that remaining time was sufficient to complete the order before time.
(C)The quality of bolts produced by SP20 is higher than the quality of bolts produced by SP23.
WRONG. It is negating the argument and not an assumption.
(D)For any currently available bolt-producing machine other than SP20, it would be impossible to complete the order on time.
WRONG.OUT OF SCOPE.
Waiting OA.