DiyaDutta wrote:
I have doubt regarding question 1. The correct answer (C) Certain desirable traits not present in other animals allowed the wolf to become the modern dog.
How did desirable traits allow wolf to become the modern dog? Didn't evolution allow the wolf to become the modern dog?
I think you are using general reasoning rather than what the paragraph actually says when you're stating evolution to be the cause.
Had this been a normal conversation, your point would have been fairly appropriate.
But the passage doesn't talk about evolution even once.I think the GMAC doesn't want candidates to use more of general reasoning and less of the points mentioned in the paragraph. I am not sure whether the GMAC gives the candidate this much leeway that they can use a scientifically complex term such as evolution to paraphrase a few points in the choices.
But let’s try a slightly different approach that does include evolution as part of our thought process while trying to answer the question:
If one uses general reasoning along with the paragraph's information, then:
Let's assume that evolution is the correct answer as per general reasoning, but evolution isn't the sole cause of the wolf becoming the modern dog. The word evolution would also include the fact that the wolf has certain traits that allowed it to become the modern dog (arrived at this by using general reasoning). Thus, it isn't wayward to assume that evolution is somewhat equivalent to having certain special traits.
So, even if the answer choice doesn't mention the word evolution, it does indicate to one of the aspects of evolution, and
especially that aspect which is supported by the passage in the first paragraph :
but only the wolf possessed the characteristics that allowed for integration into human life, which implies social assimilation, as opposed to mere domestication, which requires only a taming of wild instincts in the animal.C is the choice that is
supported by the passage and also fits within the umbrella of evolution.
Now in case the other choices of Q1 seem alluring, the earlier post from nightblade354 is really good and squashes the other options.
A few of my thoughts:
Option A - Humans value dogs more than they value any other domestic animal.The passage doesn't seem to talk primarily talk about the value of dogs to humans. No paragraph even hints at this being its main idea.
Option B - The domestication of the wolf has no parallel in any other animal.The wolf isn't really domesticated, it is socially integrated. Now one may claim that the former is needed before the latter may occur, but we are not interested in the domestication of the wolf as much as we are with the integration because all the three paragraphs talk about social integration.
Also the phrase 'no parallel in any other animal' requires a proper comparison of the wolf and a few other animals with the comparison being the highlight of the passage. No such
detailed/important comparisons with other animals take place.
Option C - Certain desirable traits not present in other animals allowed the wolf to become the modern dog.Traits - the whole of the second paragraph is attributed to it.
The transformation of the wolf into the modern dog - the first paragraph strongly implies this and the following paragraph is the reason for why was this possible. The third paragraph is a bit different but notice that in its initial lines it already accepts the fact that the wolf and the modern dog have certain shared traits, and it goes on to cite few evidences as to when did the breeds become distinct. Seems like the correct choice.
Option D - Domestication of the wolf has been unquestionably successful.Again, the passage talks very less about domestication of the wolf. It does talk about how other animals were domesticated but it is more interested in and verbose about the wolf's social integration - its traits.
Option E - Wolves are similar to humans in several important aspects.Nowhere does the passage strongly imply this. The only similarity mentioned is in the second paragraph 'Second, wolves possess a system of social stratification remarkably similar to that of humans' and that too is just one sentence with no further implications or explanations.