amitanand wrote:
Performing a risky maneuver that required precision flying,
not only did space shuttle astronauts retrieve an orbiting satellite, it was done simultaneously while avoiding being rear-ended by a passing ultraviolet telescope.
A. not only did space shuttle astronauts retrieve an orbiting satellite, it was done simultaneously while avoiding
B. not only was an orbiting satellite retrieved by space shuttle astronauts, but they also simultaneously avoided
C. an orbiting satellite was retrieved by space shuttle astronauts who also avoided simultaneously
D. space shuttle astronauts retrieved an orbiting satellite, simultaneously while avoiding
E. space shuttle astronauts retrieved an orbiting satellite and simultaneously avoided
Hi Experts,
Could anyone look into the following question:
I was stuck between D & E.....Could anybody clarify?
thanks
-AMit
This is one of "those" questions in which one can "feel" when a structure in an answer choice does not seem to convey the intended meaning. However, it is difficult to explain WHY answer D is inferior to answer E.
Breaking down the answer choices to their core structures:
D: "Performing a risky maneuver, astronauts retrieved an orbiting satellite, simultaneously while avoiding being rear-ended by a telescope."
E: "Performing a risky maneuver, astronauts retrieved an orbiting satellite and simultaneously avoided being rear-ended by a telescope."
Issue 1: Possible Redundancy
The structure "I performed Action A WHILE SIMULTANEOUSLY performing Action B" may not technically be "Redundant." At the very least, in the cases in which the usage does seem Redundant, it is not egregiously so.
"While" is a subordinating conjunction that is used to indicate that both things are happening, so the usage alone does not always fully stress that the two actions are occurring at the same instant in time. There are times when you want to emphasize the fact that the two actions really are occurring at the same instant in time.
Consider the following examples:
ex: "The general was running towards the skirmish to engage the battalion while simultaneously urging his soldiers to fight."
If we were to drop the Adverb "simultaneously" from the sentence, it would lose some of its dramatic flair. In the given problem, I would argue that "retrieving an orbiting satellite while simultaneously avoiding being rear-ended by a telescope" might be one of those cases in which you want to emphasis the difficulty of performing both actions simultaneously.
Issue 2: the Placement of the Adverb "simultaneously"
The major issue present in answer D is the placement and usage of the Adverb "simultaneously."
Generally, when a "comma + modifying phrase" is placed at the end of, and separated from, the main clause, the result is one in which the Main Idea/Action of the preceding clause is modified.
With this in mind, we can analyze answer D:
'.....astronauts retrieved an orbiting satellite, SIMULTANEOUSLY while avoiding being rear-ended by a telescope."
"While", as stated above, is a Conjunction.
"While avoiding being rear-ended by a telescope" is an example of a "comma + -ing"-type of Modifier in which the Implied Subject is the Subject of the Main Clause being modified: the "astronauts"
If we were to change the Modifier at the end of answer D to a Dependent Clause (in this case a Verb-less Clause):
"Astronauts retrieved an orbiting satellite SIMULTANEOUSLY while avoiding being rear-ended by a telescope."
This is a similar structure to the example above. However, because of the placement of "simultaneously," the meaning conveyed is Illogical. In this example, as well as in answer D, "simultaneously" is not used to emphasize that the two actions were done concurrently.
Since the Adverb appears BEFORE the Conjunction "while," the meaning conveyed is that the "astronauts retrieved an orbiting satellite SIMULTANEOUSLY." This does not really make any sense. You can not perform ONE action "simultaneously."
Furthermore, when compared to answer E, the double "-ing" is an inferior usage. The gerund noun phrase "being rear-ended by a telescope" sounds much better as a direct object of the verb "avoided" in answer E than the phrase does as a complement of the participle modifier "avoiding."
in other words: "...and avoided being rear-ended..." ---- comes across much better than --- "while avoiding being rear-ended"
More importantly than this issue, however, answer E fixes the placement of the Adverb "simultaneously" such that the meaning conveyed actually is "the two actions were performed simultaneously."
E: ".... astronauts retrieved an orbiting satellite AND simultaneously avoided being rear-ended..."
In answer E, it is clear that the 2nd Action "avoided" is the action performed "SIMULTANEOUSLY" with the 1st Action. In answer D, this intended meaning is not conveyed.
For the above reasons, answer E is preferred.