siddhans wrote:
Please explain your choice in detail...Why is A wrong???
Also, in choice D : consistently protect their intellectual property is this in order of Adverb, verb , adjective , noun???
The consultant explained that companies that establish successfully operations abroad protect with consistency their intellectual property, lobby government officials without tiring, and empower local managers with aggression.
A) that establish successfully operations abroad protect with consistency their intellectual property, lobby government officials without tiring, and empower local managers with aggression
B) which establish operations abroad successfully protect intellectual property consistently, lobby government officials without tiring, and empower local managers aggressively
C) that establish successful operations abroad consistently protect their intellectual property, lobby tirelessly government officials, and empower aggressive local management
D) that successfully establish operations abroad consistently protect their intellectual property, tirelessly lobby government officials, and aggressively empower local managers
E) of which operations abroad are successfully established protect their intellectual property consistently, lobby tirelessly government officials, and aggressively empower local management
I'm happy to respond.
This is a brilliant
MGMAT question. It has a sophisticated nested structure and determining the correct answer depends not only on grammar but also on
rhetoric.
(B) is wrong, because of using "
which" rather than "
that."
(C) changes the meaning: "
empower aggressive local management"
(E) is entirely wrong with the "
of which" opening
The real choice is between (A) & (D). Both are 100% grammatically correct. The split is about rhetorical values. You see, parallelism of three verbs does not require that all the adverbs be used in the same way, but at times, that structure is rhetorically effective. This parallelism in (D) is quite effective rhetorically:
//consistently protect their intellectual property,
//tirelessly lobby government officials,
and
//aggressively empower local managersThis is direct and persuasive. This drives it meaning home with great effect.
By contrast, (A) is clunky and clumsy: "
protect with consistency their intellectual property, . Using three parallel "
with" prepositions in the place of adverbs is indirect, punchless, mealy-mouthed writing. Choice (A) should be taken out back and shot. This is a horrible answer, despite the fact that it is 100% grammatically correct.
This is a split very much like what official questions often have: the SC question has two answer choices, both of which are grammatically correct, but one is flawless and the other is a rhetorical trainwreck. The GMAT loves to snag people who pay attention only to grammar.
MGMAT has crafted an excellent question here.
Let me know if anyone has any questions.
Mike