Gknight5603 wrote:
NirupaD wrote:
Correct:B
For income tax purposes, the IRS defines a house boat as having a full head with both shower and toilet and classified as a recreational watercraft.
A. as having a full head with both shower and toilet and classified as a recreational watercraft
Idiom 'Define X as Y' is correct, X and Y should be parallel but here 'house boat as having ..' is not parallel
-'having X and classified as y' is not parallel.'
B. as one that is classified as a recreational watercraft and that has a full head with both shower and toilet.
Correct
-'that is classified.. and that has a ..' is parallel.'
C. to be one which is classified as a recreational watercraft with a full head with both shower and toilet.
'define X to be Y' -incorrect idiom
D. to have a full head with both shower and toilet and being classified as a recreational watercraft.
'define X to have Y' - incorrect idiom
'have X and being y' not parallel
E. as one classified as a recreational watercraft with a full head with both shower and toilet.
'Define houseboat as one classified as y..' -houseboat not parallel with 'one classified as y'. 'one that classified as' is correct structure
could you please explain option B
aren't "One and that"
redundant in option B??
For income tax purposes, the
IRS defines a house boat B.
as one that is classified as a recreational watercraft
and that has a full head with both shower and toilet.
we are defining house boat as one [single thing] and 'that' modifies noun 'one' thing aka houseboat.
a) recreational watercraft
b) and has a full head with both shower and toilet
one makes the parallelism correct [define noun1 as noun2] and 'that' is required to describes house boats. so no redundancy.