Anandanwar wrote:
Hello,
I need some help here.
Option B says lower priced models will be released by other mobile manufacturers.
To me this seems to weaken "Pokia will become more desirable, low price alternative"
Could experts shed some light on this?
If my understanding is correct i will also like to know how do we reject the choice B and choose A.
Thanks!
Hello,
Anandanwar. Option B does not weaken the argument because we cannot assume that these other
lower-priced models of digital cameras will feature the qualities that would make the Pokia phone, ultimately,
the more desirable, low-priced alternative to currently existing models of digital cameras. These new low-priced phones might
not produce
more precise... higher quality images like the Pokia model.
How would you choose option A? Well, you might notice that A is not the OA given, so you should not be choosing it. I can see where
VeritasPrepBrandon is coming from earlier in the thread, but I take issue with the phrasing in answer choice (E), specifically
not universally accepted. This could mean that all but one person would
agree with the views of the independent analyst: consensus need not be established to lend credence to the assertions. Without the word
universally, I would find (E) a much more compelling answer. As is, I find it lacking, as though we are meant to interpret it in a way that leads to challenging the argument, and I doubt an official question would be so loose with its qualifying language. Taken as a whole, I do not see any clear-cut winner among the options given, and I would recommend getting back to official material.
Good luck with your studies.
- Andrew