Gmat700Knight wrote:
Hello, people, let’s knock this one out. I have to say I wasn’t, though I got to the answer in roughly a minute, too pleased with this one’s answer choice.
In preparation for the cold winter months, it was the usual custom for prehistoric people to gather and preserve, with smoke or by salting it, as much meat that they could during the summer.
(A) it was the usual custom for prehistoric people to gather and preserve, with smoke or by salting it, as much meat that they could during the summer.
In preparation... would have to modify a person(s) generally. This is a freebie elimination since the first part modifies it nonsensically.
(B) prehistoric people usually gathered as much meat as they could during the summer, preserving it either by smoking or salting
So, the modification looks good. In preparation.... prehistoric people. Yes. What else? Ah, I see an either/ or. Let’s check the parallelism... Now here’s what I don't like, people: Either/or should be ridiculously parallel. Here, the case could be made that it should be either by smoking or by salting. On the actual exam raise a yellow flag here and move on.
(C) it was the usual custom of prehistoric people to gather and preserve, either with smoke or by salting, as much meat that they could during the summer
As explained above with (A) this is another Freebie elimination because of the nonsensical modification of it
(D) prehistoric people had the usual custom of gathering and preserving as much meat, either by smoking or salting it, as they could during the summer
I would have hoped this would have fixed the either/or issue. But what smacks first is the nonsensical, awkward had. There is no need for it, and there is a theory that unless there are TWO past events, one taking place before another, you do not need this in a sentence. I still, mind you, might have chosen this if the either/or part had been more parallel than (B). As it stands, however, the same exact word choice is used; so this one is just a worse version of (B)
(E) it was usually that prehistoric people would gather and preserve as much meat as they could, which was either smoked or salted during the summer
Same dangling modifier issue as (A) and (C)
So, we end up with (B), people. The knight disapproves!
From what I understand about the Verbing's, I don't think usage of Verbing is appropriate either in this sentence. It is neither describing the How part nor the result part. People gathered meat, preserving it ... doesn't make sense with that perspective.
I will just leave this sentence and not bother on it at all. A very poorly written SC question in my opinion.