Pankaj0901 wrote:
The option E sounds very weird to me.
e) fantastic elements mainstream literature and thus exclude these works and thus exclude these works
"fantastic elements mainstream literature" - how are these 4 words connected to each other?
fantastic - adjective, which is modifying "elements"
elements - a noun...so, is it elements "of" mainstream literature?
mainstream - adjective, which is modifying "literature"
literature - noun
=> fantastic elements mainstream literature [if modifiers are omitted]
If read together with the main sentence: The term "genre novel" is loosely defined, promoted by those critics who do not consider novels that rely on romantic relationships, crime drama, or fantastic elements mainstream literature and thus exclude these works.
It sounds like something is missing between the words "elements" and "literature", as the relationship is not properly established between the two.
Request experts to please explain this. zhanbo - could you please help here. Thanks in advance.
neetakarnik wrote:
The term "genre novel" is loosely defined, promoted by those critics who do not consider novels that rely on romantic relationships, crime drama, or
use fantastic elements to be mainstream literature and thus exclude these from consideration when awarding literary prizes.
a) use fantastic elements to be mainstream literature and thus exclude these
b) fantastic elements mainstream literature and thus exclude these
c) use fantastic elements as mainstream literature and thus exclude these works
d) fantastic elements as if they were mainstream literature and thus exclude these
e) fantastic elements mainstream literature and thus exclude these works
I am a little confused as it seems that there should be an "as" after mainstream in the fifth option?
Here is how I understand the structure of the sentence as written by option (E).
The term "genre novel" is loosely defined, promoted by those critics who do not consider novels that rely on romantic relationships, crime drama, or fantastic elements mainstream literature and thus exclude these works."fantastic elements" is part of the list X, Y, or
Z (romantic relationships, crime drama, or
fantastic elements) in the restrictive clause that modifies novels. (X, Y, Z should maintain parallelism. We can eliminate option A and C this way.)
If we remove the whole clause for a moment, we get:
"those critics who do not consider ("genre") novels mainstream literature ..."
Consider, as a transitive verb, can mean "to think of someone or something in a particular way". As the examples at
https://www.oxfordlearnersdictionaries. ... h/consider show,
consider can be used in multiple ways:
consider somebody/something + nounconsider somebody/something (to be) somethingconsider somebody/something (as) something // as can be omitted.
Examples: He considers himself an expert on the subject.
Similarly: They consider genre novels mainstream literature.
They do not consider genre novels mainstream literature.