_________________

http://gmatclub.com/forum/math-polygons-87336.html
http://gmatclub.com/forum/competition-for-the-best-gmat-error-log-template-86232.html

Question #13. I beg your pardon but "child labor and industrial home work were equally inhumane practices that should be outlawed" as according to the answers IS NOT the line #17 but just lines 13-14. Line 17 is "Given the precarious finances of
working-class families ...". So I've got E instead of B. Why I am wrong?

Hi there,

I'm reviewing the responses for this particular question and am seeing a lot of inconsistencies. And where I see commonalities in users' responses, I disagree with them. Should this proper answer to this question not be as follows?


12) The primary purpose of this passage is to... D - Discuss an oversight on the part of women reformers of the Progressive Era
13) The view mentioned in line 17 ("Working class mothers did not always share this view, Given the precarious finances...") refers to which of the following? - B - Reformer's belief that child labor and industrial home work should be abolished
14) The author of the passage mentions the observations of women historians ("Working class mothers did not always share this view...") most probably in order to... A - Provide support for an assertion made in the preceding sentence lines (lines 10-12)
15) The passage suggests that which of the following was a reason for the difference of opinion between working class mothers and reformers? E - Working class families need for every employable member of their families to earn money
16) The author of the passage asserts which of the following about women reformers who tried to abolish child labor? C - They were correct in their conviction that child labor was deplorable but shortsighted about the impact child labor legislation had on working class families
17) According to the passage, one of the most striking achievements of middle-class women reformers during the progressive era was... E - improving women's and children's working conditions

To summarize: My argument is that the correct answers for this reading passage are as follows: D, B , A, E, C, E

While I like to discuss these topics, what I like more is a consistent answer at the end of the thread, so that other people (like myself), can take that as a validated answer by the community. When a thread is left like this with multiple and different responses, it doesn't us any good, and leaves things pretty vague. I look forward to your feedback, all.


Best,

Tim

Hi Friends and mikemcgarry,
"The author of the passage asserts which of the following about women reformers who tried to abolish child labor?
A They alienated working-class mothers by attempting to enlist them in agitating for progressive causes.
B They underestimated the prevalence of child labor among the working classes.
C They were correct in their conviction that child labor was deplorable but shortsighted about the impact of child labor legislation on working-class families.
D They were aggressive in their attempts to enforce child labor legislation, but were unable to prevent working-class families from circumventing them.
E They were prevented by their nearly total disenfranchisement from making significant progress in child labor reform"

I have a problem with D in this question. First I struggled C and D, although I got C eventually, but I have no idea what's problem with D,
I read the OA, it says "the reformers' activities involved prompted legislation; there is no evidence in the passage that the reformers themselves attempted to enforce these laws."

Would you please help how should I figure out it is "the reformers' activities, not reformers themselves

thanks in advance
have a nice day
>_~

Hi mikemcgarry, thanks so much indeed.
I've heard that , in USA, the demonstrators would do their jobs before the law passed, but I have never combined my heard with this question.

For law, as a generally citizen, I have narrow knowledge about it , as I know, the people who maintain the what the law is and the people who make what is the law are different.

Have a nice day
>_~

Q.1 The primary purpose of the passage is to
Tone of the passage is neutral; Key line is - "working-class mothers did not always share this view" ; passage starts with citing work done by the reformers and then explores the oversight of middle class women and reformers.
A explain why women reformers of the Progressive Era failed to achieve their goals
<no such failure has been mentioned; misunderstanding of a view doesn't mean failure of a goal - incorrect >
B discuss the origins of child labor laws in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries
<none of the origins has been mentioned - incorrect >
C compare the living conditions of working-class and middle-class women in the Progressive Era
<no such comparison made - incorrect >
D discuss an oversight on the part of women reformers of the Progressive Era
<correct>
E revise a traditional view of the role played by women reformers in enacting Progressive Era reforms
<view of the role played by the women reformers is nowhere revised in the passage - incorrect >


Q.2 The view mentioned in the highlight text of the passage refers to which of the following?
Specific detail question that is mentioned in the line - it is reformers view - "To the reformers, child labor and industrial home work were equally inhumane practices that should be outlawed"
A Some working-class mothers' resistance to the enforcement of child labor laws
< we need reformers view not the WCM's view - incorrect >
B Reformers' belief that child labor and industrial home work should be abolished
<correct>
C Reformers' opinions about how working-class families raised their children
<no such opinion referred near the "view" - attribution to the wrong segment of the passage - incorrect >
D Certain women historians' observation that there was a lack of consensus between women of different classes on the issue of child labor and industrial home work
<it is not reformers' view - incorrect >
E Working-class families' fears about the adverse consequences that child labor laws would have on their ability to earn an adequate living
<we need reformers' view - incorrect >


Q.3 The author of the passage mentions the observations of women historians (the highlight text) most probably in order to
A provide support for an assertion made in the preceding sentence
B raise a question that is answered in the last sentence of the passage
C introduce an opinion that challenges a statement made in the first sentence of the passage
D offer an alternative view to the one attributed in the passage to working-class mothers
E point out a contradiction inherent in the traditional view of child labor reform as it is presented in the passage

How to differentiate among answer options - A, B, and E?


Q.4 The passage suggests that which of the following was a reason for the difference of opinion between working class mothers and women reformers on the issue of child labor?
Failure to understand the financial reason that is mentioned in the passage
A Reformers' belief that industrial home work was preferable to child labor outside the home
<no such comparison is made - incorrect >
B Reformers' belief that child labor laws should pertain to working conditions but not to pay
<out of context - incorrect >
C Working-class mothers' resentment at reformers' attempts to interfere with their parenting
<no such "resentment" has been mentioned - incorrect >
D Working-class mothers' belief that child labor was an inhumane practice
<out of scope - incorrect >
E Working-class families' need for every employable member of their families to earn money
<As stated in the passage - correct >


Q.5 The author of the passage asserts which of the following about women reformers who tried to abolish child labor?
The relevant information is present in the first two lines of the passage
A They alienated working-class mothers by attempting to enlist them in agitating for progressive causes.
<out of context - incorrect >
B They underestimated the prevalence of child labor among the working classes.
<out of scope - incorrect >
C They were correct in their conviction that child labor was deplorable but shortsighted about the impact of child labor legislation on working-class families.
< Correct >
D They were aggressive in their attempts to enforce child labor legislation, but were unable to prevent working-class families from circumventing them.
< hyper statement - no such event mentioned in the passage - incorrect >
E They were prevented by their nearly total disenfranchisement from making significant progress in child labor reform.
< incorrect C->E correlation mentioned - incorrect >

Q.6 According to the passage, one of the most striking achievements of white middle-class women reformers during the progressive Era was
Specific detail question directly from the line - "white middle-class women reformers won a variety of victories, notably in the improvement of working conditions, especially for women and children."
A gaining the right to vote in school elections
< tweaking the information present in the passage - incorrect >
B mobilizing working-class women in the fight against child labor
<action attributed to the wrong class - out of scope - incorrect >
C uniting women of different classes in grassroots activism
<180 turn - incorrect>
D improving the economic conditions of working- class families
<out of scope - incorrect>
E improving women's and children's working conditions
<correct>

What do you think about the reasons mentioned above to reject the wrong answer options?


Regards,
Akash
_________________

A lot needs to be learned from all of you.

All Correct (yay!)
Time taken : - 8 mins 34 seconds
_________________

My journey From 410 to 700
Here's my experience when I faced a glitch in my GMAT Exam
Don't do this mistake when you give your GMATPrep Mock!
NEW GMATPrep software analysis by Bunuel

Hey Dkingdom

I actually tried that approach in which I took notes from the passage and guess what my accuracy was very poor while solving passages. I read GMATNinja's article regarding RCs in which he said to look at the bigger picture and try to understand what the author is trying to convey. With this new approach, my accuracy increased to 90%

I always refer back to the passage if I am unclear about the answer.

Hope this helps
_________________

My journey From 410 to 700
Here's my experience when I faced a glitch in my GMAT Exam
Don't do this mistake when you give your GMATPrep Mock!
NEW GMATPrep software analysis by Bunuel

3. The author of the passage mentions the observations of women historians (the highlight text)[women historians have recently observed] most probably in order to
A provide support for an assertion made in the preceding sentence
B raise a question that is answered in the last sentence of the passage
C introduce an opinion that challenges a statement made in the first sentence of the passage
D offer an alternative view to the one attributed in the passage to working-class mothers
E point out a contradiction inherent in the traditional view of child labor reform as it is presented in the passage


women historians have recently observed, working-class mothers did not always share this view.
Historian observation is in contradiction with previous sentence.(before highlighted text) but answer is given as A.

Kindly help