myleo wrote:
BschoolBound2014 wrote:
Received my invite to interview today off the waitlist! Needless to say I am very excited to have been given new life.
you got in tuck. you have to be absolutely crazy to attend nyu if you get it at tuck or duke.
What you want to do matters a lot in deciding between these three schools. Duke edges out Stern in management consulting for the top tier places, but its likely you will then be working in the southern offices of said top tier places. Tuck will have better odds of placing you in the northeast. Stern is a finance school and blows Tuck and Duke away in regards to access to investment banks; it also has the best access to NYC.
The three schools flip around in order of ranking in any given year and at this point hold relatively similar prestige. Almost anyone would consider these three schools (along with Berkeley and maybe Yale) in the same 'tier', but these schools do not have all the same recruiters. Each school gives you access to different networks with different strengths and weaknesses. Which of those three someone would select comes entirely down to what the person wants to do. If someone wants to work in anything finance, Stern is your choice. If someone wants management consulting at BCG from Stern, its still doable, just more difficult than coming from Duke or Dartmouth. That Stern student will still have excellent odds of being hired by Deloitte Consulting or Booz. If someone wants to work in NYC, a Stern student is going to have a significant advantage in networking over students at the other two. If someone wants to work in the Silicon Valley tech space, Berkeley has an obvious edge. If someone wants to be in the non-profit space, its practically required to go to Yale.
Applicants need to do their homework as to how the school will impact their career track. Each of these schools can enable people, but in very noticeably different ways. The best thing an applicant can do is talk to current students to learn about the recruiting environment for the fields the applicant is interested in. If someone decided between these schools solely based on rank when the US News point difference between these schools is miniscule, he would be doing himself a disservice.