McDuck99
Hi,
This is my first post as it calls for it now. At the moment, I feel lost and need some serious guidance.
I filled 3 b-schools applications - INSEAD (Jan'24 Round 1), IESE (Round 3), and HEC Paris (March Round) with a modest score of 700 GMAT (Q50, V35) but got rejected from all three. I was banking on my profile and work experience, considering the opinions of consultants and alums I spoke to, and who said that I have a somewhat different profile and that if I leverage it, I have good chances. A bit about my profile - Indian, male engineer from BITS Pilani, 1-year experience in IT consulting, shifted to the social sector, 1 year worked with a member of parliament, 3 years in impact consulting, 1 year in strategic healthcare consulting. For international exposure, I lived in Saudi Arabia for half of my life and worked with clients in the US. I intended to work in tier 1 management consulting with a long-term goal of starting a social enterprise. I have decent Acads (GPA 3 out of 4), a few leadership roles at college, and started a social enterprise. I worked with a consultant to collate all this information and come up with 'decent' essays for b-schools application (considering the scope of improvement here).
With this, I was expecting at least an interview invite at INSEAD or HEC but I guess they have called in people with high GMAT scores (based on the
decision tracker and discussions here on GMAT Club). So as per my analysis, the GMAT score could be the prime reason for rejection. And now I'm planning to apply to Round 1 for US b-schools in fall'23.
So, I have come up with two options - either I apply to lower-ranked colleges where 700 would be decent enough to get into or take GRE, score 325+, and target high-ranked schools.
What would be your suggestion and why?How I have come up with these two options? Firstly, I have already given 4 GMAT attempts in the last 1.5 years. I scored 700 only after the 650 score plateau. So I believe going beyond 700 is uncertain, and might take a lot of time and effort. Secondly, I researched about GRE and I feel it is relatively easier (or maybe the grass is greener on the other side) and doesn't test grammar which was dreadful for me in GMAT. I know I would need to learn vocabulary in detail but since I have a knack for memorizing things, I may be able to perform well. Plus, I have 4 months till August, so I can prep for 2 months, and dedicate 2 months to the b-school application.
Please let me know if you need any additional data points for advising, happy to tell you more.
Also, please spare me if I missed any norms of posting.

Hi
McDuck99 For HEC and IESE, it may be because of the late rounds given the competitive pool you belong to. European schools (speaking from my experience at INSEAD) look at your GMAT score individually for the Quant and Verbal sections. Your Quant score is comparable with your demographic's average at INSEAD. The schools tend to be somewhat forgiving of non-native speakers' performance in Verbal if they have an overall impressive profile. Therefore, while having a stellar GMAT score may increase your chances of receiving an interview invitation from INSEAD, a low GMAT score may not be the only reason for not receiving an invitation.
BITs Pilani is a Tier 1 undergrad, but you did not mention your undergrad academic performance.
Your professional history appears to be filled with a variety of experiences, but it is unclear whether they reflect a clear plan or a strong motivation in a specific direction. Although I am glad to note your recent involvement in the consulting sector, I hope that you did not undervalue your potential in your essays as well as in your professional recommendations.
It is not evident from your brief whether you have solely resided or have also been employed in Saudi Arabia. While growing up at the intersection of different cultures in a foreign land is interesting, a majority of INSEAD students possess some full-time international work experience. Thus, your most recent experiences hold the most significance in your application's decision.
To enhance your performance on the verbal section of the GMAT, seeking professional assistance and identifying areas of focus can help you quickly improve your score. It is not necessary to excel in all aspects of verbal but having strong proficiency in 2 out of 3 areas can suffice to achieve your desired score. Keeping an
error log on an excel sheet for verbal concepts and questions is beneficial in identifying repeated mistakes and correcting them. This practice will aid in strengthening your verbal skills. Switching to the GRE at this juncture could be unpredictable. Take mock exams to determine your pace of improvement on GRE.
Best wishes
Thanks for your detailed reply. It gives me some direction.
One follow-up question - by taking GRE, would I hurt my chances of applying to all the schools because I think not all of them are GRE-friendly? Case in point: INSEAD.