Hi inciduntveniam,Great catch, and the fix is to notice that
Q1 and Q7 are two different situations, even though both involve even powers.
Q7 (where ±5 and ±2 are both kept): the equation is x4 = 29x2 - 100. There is
no root sign here. When you solve it you reach x2 =
25 and x2 =
4. Solving x2 =
25 means asking "what values of x, when squared, give
25?" - and that is
both +5 and -5. Same for x2 =
4, giving
+2 and -2. So all
four values are legitimate. Nothing forces x to be positive.
Q1 (where -2 is thrown out): the equation is x = 4√(x3 + 6x2). Look at the left side: x is set
equal to a 4th-root expression. A root sign like √ or 4√ is an operation that only ever outputs a
non-negative number (4√
16 =
2, never
-2). So whatever x equals, it must be
≥ 0. That's why the candidate x =
-2 fails - plug it in and you get 4√
16 =
2, so you'd be claiming
-2 =
2, which is false.
The one distinction to hold onto:- x2 =
25 -
two answers,
+5 and
-5 (you're solving an equation).
- x = √
25 -
one answer,
+5 (you're reading the output of a root sign, which is never negative).
Q7 is the first case. Q1 is the second case - x is literally
equal to a root, so it inherits the root's non-negative restriction.
Quick self-test to lock it in:- How many solutions does y2 =
9 have? (Two:
+3 and
-3.)
- What is √
9? (Just
3.)
Same numbers, different question - and that difference is exactly what separates Q1 from Q7.
Answer: Dinciduntveniam
Hi Bunuel!
Why did you not take -2 and +2 ? Why the or condition considered on for x^2 = 2 and not for x^2 = 25 ? For the latter both -5 and +5 were taken.