We are looking for an option
most strongly supports -
A is logically valid, but
partial – it focuses on one side (apologizer) and only on sincerity of that action.
E covers
full scope of the passage: both
sincere offering and sincere acceptance, and the
shared condition (acknowledgment of a wrong) necessary for both.
which is why E is preferred over A I believe. Please correct me if you have different perspective arriving at the solution and my reasoning doesn't make any sense
nishant8780
ok. But both sincere offer and acceptance, there are two condition for each. And option E mentions only one of them ( the common one). So how option e is correct then ?
Krunaal
A. If one apologizes and subsequently repeats the wrongful act for which one has apologized, then one has not apologized sincerely.- This seems plausible but is not explicitly required by the argument. The passage explains that sincerity in an apology requires the intent not to repeat the wrongful act, but it does not explicitly link the act of repeating it to insincerity in every case. The person, at the time, might really intend to not repeat the wrongful act and apologize sincerely, yet unwillingly or willingly at some point in future the act gets repeated, that does not render the past apology insincere.
Incorrect.
B. One cannot sincerely accept an apology that was not sincerely offered.- The passage does not connect the sincerity of acceptance to the sincerity of the apology. Acceptance depends on the receiver’s acknowledgment of the wrong and their vow not to hold a grudge, regardless of the sincerity of the apology.
Incorrect.
C. If one commits a wrongful act, then one should sincerely apologize for that act.- The passage outlines what constitutes a sincere apology but does not state that one must always apologize for every wrongful act.
Incorrect.
D. An apology that cannot be sincerely accepted cannot be sincerely offered.- The passage treats the sincerity of an apology and the sincerity of its acceptance as separate entities, each requiring acknowledgment of the wrongful act. There is no indication that an apology’s sincerity depends on whether it can be accepted.
Incorrect.
E. An apology cannot be both sincerely offered and sincerely accepted unless each person acknowledges that a wrongful act has occurred.- This aligns with the passage’s reasoning.
- A sincere apology requires acknowledgment of a wrongful act.
- A sincere acceptance also requires acknowledgment of a wrongful act.
- Without mutual acknowledgment of the wrongful act, neither the apology nor the acceptance can meet the criteria of sincerity.
Correct.
Answer E.RaahimAsadShah
How is the answer not A? I find A and E to be similar. When attempting this question I had narrowed down to A and E.