tyildirim92 wrote:
Quote:
(C) The taxes and fees associated with importing microchips from Country P to Country K are less than 15 percent of the cost of manufacturing those microchips in Country K.
It seems like even C is a problematic choice, which makes the question wrong. Please note the following reasoning and all figures below are in line with the prompt,
Cost in Country K, K:$115
Cost in CountRy P, P:$100
According to choice C, the taxes and fees associated with importing microchips from Country P to Country K are less than 15 percent of the cost of manufacturing those microchips in Country K, namely less than 15/100*115=$17.25. Ups, that's bad. Let us say the taxes and fees associated with importing microchips from Country P to Country K are exactly 17. In such a case, because 17 is greater than 15,(15=the real cost difference according to above), it would not be wise to say even after customs taxes and delivery fees are considered, it is still cheaper for Country K to import microchips from Country P than to have the microchips manufactured domestically.
My humble suggestion is that choice C be replaced with the below sentence.
The taxes and fees associated with importing microchips from Country P to Country K are less than 15 percent of the cost of manufacturing those microchips in Country
P.Experts,
GMATNinja,
VeritasKarishma,
MentorTutoring please confirm my reasoning,
Everyone, please kudos if you find this post helpful!
Hello,
tyildirim92, and thank you for tagging me. I can appreciate the point you are making; at the same time, I think you are working against the
given fact from the prompt that
it is still cheaper for Country K to import microchips from Country P than to have the microchips manufactured domestically. Your aim is not to disprove the established condition, but to take it as true and assess the answer choices with such a premise in mind. So, provided it
is, in fact, cheaper for K to import microchips than to manufacture them, using the same numbers you have outlined above, we can assume that the taxes and fees for importing microchips must be less than $15, without doing any math. Perhaps for the more mathematically inclined test-taker, your proposed change of K to P would make more sense, but GMAC™ makes it quite clear that it is
conclusions, not premises, that are to be weakened, if anything at all. Besides, an amount lower than $15 would still qualify as being
less than 15 percent of the cost of manufacturing those microchips in Country K. It might not be as satisfying an answer, but with the information presented in the passage, and considering the position GMAC™ has adopted regarding premises, choice (C) is fine as is.
- Andrew