Official Solution:
The section’s new manager is limited in his effectiveness because he is convinced that, of all the possible methods for monitoring progress, the most effective is to check on his employees every few minutes.
A. the most effective is to check on
B. it is the most effective checking in on
C. the one that is most effective is to check on
D. the most effective method is checking on
E. the most effective one is to check upon
A. After the adjective “effective”, a noun or a pronoun is required. It is sometimes alright to omit a repeated word in a sentence in order to make the sentence concise, but here the required word “method” does not occur anywhere else in the sentence and hence must not be omitted (even though its plural form “methods” occur elsewhere.) Use of the infinitive vs. gerund: in this case gerund is preferred but not incorrect to use infinitive either. On the GMAT, however, Infinitives are preferred to express purpose.
B. The pronoun “it” doesn't have an antecedent. A noun or a pronoun is missing after the adjective “effective”.
C. “The one that is most effective” is unnecessarily wordy - “most effective one” is more concise. Use of the infinitive “to check” is incorrect - gerund “checking” is better as explained in A.
D. CORRECT. After the adjective “effective”, the noun “method” is correctly used. The gerund ”checking” is appropriately used. Infinitive would be OK to use as well with some perhaps arguing gerund is slightly more correct to be used as noun but both could have been acceptable
E. Use of the infinitive “to check” is incorrect - gerund “checking” is better as explained in A. “Check upon” is not idiomatic.
Answer: D
_________________