Author 
Message 
TAGS:

Hide Tags

Manager
Joined: 18 Oct 2008
Posts: 191

There are 70 students in Math or English or German. Exactly 40 are in [#permalink]
Show Tags
21 Jul 2010, 02:43
1
This post received KUDOS
1
This post was BOOKMARKED
Question Stats:
100% (01:44) correct
0% (00:00) wrong based on 4 sessions
HideShow timer Statistics
There are 70 students in Math or English or German. Exactly 40 are in Math, 30 in German, 35 in English and 15 in all three courses. How many students are enrolled in exactly two of the courses? Math, English and German. please explain your answers. what is the significance of 'exactly' (Exactly 40 are in Math, 30 in German, 35 in English ) in the stem?



Manager
Joined: 20 Jul 2010
Posts: 77

Re: There are 70 students in Math or English or German. Exactly 40 are in [#permalink]
Show Tags
21 Jul 2010, 03:45
I am getting answer as:50. Looks to me,exactly is a redundant word.
*** n(MUEUG) = n(M) + n(E) + n(G)  n(M & E)  n(E&G)  n(G&M) +n(M&E&G)
70 = 40 + 35+ 30  n(M & E)  n(E&G)  n(G&M) + 15 Then, n(M & E) + n(E&G) + n(G&M) = 50.
So students who enrolled in two of the courses are: 50 ***



Ms. Big Fat Panda
Status: Three Down.
Joined: 09 Jun 2010
Posts: 1918
Concentration: General Management, Nonprofit

Re: There are 70 students in Math or English or German. Exactly 40 are in [#permalink]
Show Tags
21 Jul 2010, 06:43
2
This post received KUDOS
I think the OA makes perfect sense. And you cannot just ignore the term exactly. Exactly two means that they are not enrolled in all three classes. The simplest way to extract info from what's given is to draw a Venn Diagram. Attachment: File comment: Venn Diagram
c73058.jpg [ 19.92 KiB  Viewed 1778 times ]
So, from this picture, we are asked to find out what \(x+y+z\) is. Let's look at given information and form the constraints: Total = 70\(x+y+z+a+b+c+15 = 70\) \((x+y+z) + (a+b+c) = 55\)Total Math = 40\(x+y+a+15 = 40\) \(x+y = 25a\)Total German = 30\(y+z+c+15 = 30\) \(y+z = 15 c\)Total English = 35\(x+z+b+15 = 35\) \(x+z = 20b\)So now combining all the bolded equations regarding totals of each subject we get \(2(x+y+z) = 15+25+20  (a+b+c) = 60  (a+b+c)\)So \((a+b+c) = 60  2(x+y+z)\)Now substituting this into the first equation regarding total students, we get \( (x+y+z) + 60  2(x+y+z) = 55\) Hence \(x+y+z = 5\)nravi4: The mistake you made in getting 50 is this. You counted the students enrolled in two of three subjects, but not strictly so. So your calculation includes the central space of 15 which is students enrolled in all three subjects for each subject you counted. So to get to the answer from your answer you need to do \(50  (3*15) = 5\) Hope this is clear.



Manager
Joined: 20 Jul 2010
Posts: 77

Re: There are 70 students in Math or English or German. Exactly 40 are in [#permalink]
Show Tags
21 Jul 2010, 07:38
Oho...yaaa..i missed the last step of subtracting 15 from M&E, E&G, G&M to match the work "Exactly" ...
Basically, the below is what the question is asking:
n(M & E)  n(M&E&G) + n(E&G) n(M&E&G) + n(G&M)  n(M&E&G)
Cheers! Ravi



Manager
Joined: 20 Jul 2010
Posts: 189

Re: There are 70 students in Math or English or German. Exactly 40 are in [#permalink]
Show Tags
21 Jul 2010, 08:18
2
This post received KUDOS
for venn diagrams in case of 3 cases: Total = m(a) + m(b) + m(c) + m(a&b) + m(b&c) + m(c&a)  2*m(a&b&c) So, 70 = 40 + 30 + 35  m(a&b)  m(b&c)  m(c&a)  2*15 => 35 =  [ m(a&b) + m(b&c) + m(c&a) ]  30 Therefore, m(a&b) + m(b&c) + m(c&a) = 5
_________________
Gotta hit the 700 score this time... 3rd time lucky ! Give me some kudos... Like you, even I need them badly



Manager
Joined: 18 Oct 2008
Posts: 191

Re: There are 70 students in Math or English or German. Exactly 40 are in [#permalink]
Show Tags
22 Jul 2010, 02:46
whiplash2411 wrote: I think the OA makes perfect sense. And you cannot just ignore the term exactly. Exactly two means that they are not enrolled in all three classes. The simplest way to extract info from what's given is to draw a Venn Diagram. Attachment: c73058.jpg So, from this picture, we are asked to find out what \(x+y+z\) is. Let's look at given information and form the constraints: Total = 70\(x+y+z+a+b+c+15 = 70\) \((x+y+z) + (a+b+c) = 55\)Total Math = 40\(x+y+a+15 = 40\) \(x+y = 25a\)Total German = 30\(y+z+c+15 = 30\) \(y+z = 15 c\)Total English = 35\(x+z+b+15 = 35\) \(x+z = 20b\)So now combining all the bolded equations regarding totals of each subject we get \(2(x+y+z) = 15+25+20  (a+b+c) = 60  (a+b+c)\)So \((a+b+c) = 60  2(x+y+z)\)Now substituting this into the first equation regarding total students, we get \( (x+y+z) + 60  2(x+y+z) = 55\) Hence \(x+y+z = 5\)nravi4: The mistake you made in getting 50 is this. You counted the students enrolled in two of three subjects, but not strictly so. So your calculation includes the central space of 15 which is students enrolled in all three subjects for each subject you counted. So to get to the answer from your answer you need to do \(50  (3*15) = 5\) Hope this is clear. Hi cant we take 'a' as 40 here as it is mentioned exactly 40 on math?



Ms. Big Fat Panda
Status: Three Down.
Joined: 09 Jun 2010
Posts: 1918
Concentration: General Management, Nonprofit

Re: There are 70 students in Math or English or German. Exactly 40 are in [#permalink]
Show Tags
22 Jul 2010, 06:07
It says that exactly 40 are in math, not that 40 are in ONLY math. The people who take Math and English or Math and German or even all three are also in math, aren't they not? So you can't take a to be 40 since 40 is the sum of a,x, y and 15, i.e. people who take only Math, people who take Math and English, people who take Math and German and people who take all three. Hope this is clear.



Manager
Joined: 18 Oct 2008
Posts: 191

Re: There are 70 students in Math or English or German. Exactly 40 are in [#permalink]
Show Tags
22 Jul 2010, 08:35
whiplash2411 wrote: It says that exactly 40 are in math, not that 40 are in ONLY math. The people who take Math and English or Math and German or even all three are also in math, aren't they not? So you can't take a to be 40 since 40 is the sum of a,x, y and 15, i.e. people who take only Math, people who take Math and English, people who take Math and German and people who take all three. Hope this is clear. Thank you! got mixed up with 'exactly' and 'only'




Re: There are 70 students in Math or English or German. Exactly 40 are in
[#permalink]
22 Jul 2010, 08:35







