Car X is 40 miles west of Car Y. Both cars are traveling east, and Car

Question

Car X is 40 miles west of Car Y. Both cars are traveling east, and Car X is going 50% faster than Car Y. If both cars travel at a constant rate and it takes Car X 2 hours and 40 minutes to catch up to Car Y, how fast is Car Y going?

A. 20 miles per hour
B. 25 miles per hour
C. 30 miles per hour
D. 35 miles per hour
E. 40 miles per hour

Let speed of Y = V ,
speed of X = 1.5 V,
relative speed of X wrt Y (catch up speed of X) = 0.5V.
Now catch up speed = (distance between X and Y)/time.

0.5 V = 40 miles / (8/3 hour),
so V = 30 miles/hr.

However, what I don't understand is that the distance traveled by Car Y while Car X is catching up is not factored into the problem. Could someone clarify if my concern is valid, if not then reason.

Thanks,
Kiran

Bunuel · Accepted Answer

Say the rate of Car Y is y miles per hour and the rate of Car X is 1.5y miles per hour..

Since they are traveling in the same direction their relative speed is 1.5y - y = 0.5y = y/2 miles per hour.

Time*Rate = Distance --> (8/3)*(y/2) = 40 --> y = 30 miles per hour.

WholeLottaLove · Answer

Car X is 40 miles west of Car Y. Both cars are traveling east, and Car X is going 50% faster than Car Y. If both cars travel at a constant rate and it takes Car X 2 hours and 40 minutes to catch up to Car Y, how fast is Car Y going?

Basically, this problem is no different than if Y were stationary and it took x 2.66 hours to catch up to it. However, we need to consider that they are moving and that car X is traveling at a speed 1.5times y.

Speed of y = y
Speed of x = 1.5y
distance = 40

The relative speed of x compared to y is 1.5y - y = 0.5y

time = distance/speed
8/3 = 40/0.5y
4y=120
y=30

We use the relative speed in this formula (as opposed to the speed of x or y) because it's in the context of the time and distance x must cover to reach y. Thus, we use the relative speed of x compared to y. Once we obtain y, we can plug it into the actual speeds of x and y (1.5y and y respectively)

speed of y = 30

BrentGMATPrepNow · Answer

Let's let Car X's original position be the initial starting point. 
So, when Car X is at the initial starting point, Car Y has already traveled 40 miles.

My  word equation  involves the conditions when Car X  catches up  to Car Y. 
At that point, we can say: 
 Car X's TOTAL distance traveled  =  Car Y's TOTAL distance traveled

Car Y's total distance 
Let V = Car Y's speed ( our goal is to find the value of V )
From the time that Car X begins moving, Car Y drives for 2 2/3 hours (2 hours, 40 minutes). 
So Car Y's total distance = (time)(speed) = (2 2/3)(V) + 40 miles

Car X's total distance 
We know that Car X is going 50% faster than Car Y. If Car Y's rate is V, then Car X's rate must be 1.5V 
We also know that Car X travels for 2 2/3 hours. 
So Car X's total distance = (time)(speed) = (2 2/3)(1.5V) miles
Simplify: (2 2/3)(1.5V) = (8/3)(3/2) = 4V

We're now ready to write our algebraic equation.
 Car X's total distance  =  Car Y's total distance 
 4V  =  (2 2/3)(V) + 40 miles 
4/3V = 40
V = 40(3/4)
 V = 30
 
Cheers,
Brent

patternpandora · Answer

How did we arrive to 8/3 hours.... as its given 2.40 hours which is 160 mins.... what have I mistaken out here, can someone point it out to me.

Thanks in advance!

christianbze · Answer

You have to convert 160 minutes into hours because it is asked for mph!

\frac{160}{60} = \frac{16}{6} = \frac{8}{3}

You could also do that in the end:

(1.5y-1y)\frac{m}{h} x 160min = 40miles

0.5y\frac{m}{h} = \frac{40miles}{160min}

y\frac{m}{h} = \frac{80miles}{160min} = \frac{1miles}{2min} = \frac{60miles}{2hours} = 30\frac{miles}{hour}

Bunuel · Answer

2 hours and 40 minutes =  2\frac{2}{3}  hours=  \frac{8}{3}  hours.

ROckHIsT · Answer

Do you have more such question in relative speed?

Bunuel · Answer

Theory on Distance/Rate Problems: distance-speed-time-word-problems-made-easy-87481.html

All DS Distance/Rate Problems to practice: search.php?search_id=tag&tag_id=44
All PS Distance/Rate Problems to practice: search.php?search_id=tag&tag_id=64

PareshGmat · Answer

Let speed of Y = V ,
speed of X = 1.5 V,
relative speed of X wrt Y (catch up speed of X) = 0.5V.
Now catch up speed = (distance between X and Y)/time.

0.5 V = 40 miles / (8/3 hour),
so V = 30 miles/hr.

However, what I don't understand is that the distance traveled by Car Y while Car X is catching up is not factored into the problem. Could someone clarify if my concern is valid, if not then reason.

Thanks,
Kiran  ]

Refer diagram below

160 Mins = \frac{160}{60} Hrs = \frac{8}{3}

Time required by X to reach catch point = Time required by Y to reach catch point  = \frac{8}{3}

\frac{40+d}{\frac{150s}{100}} = \frac{d}{s}

3d = 2d + 80

d = 80

s = \frac{80}{\frac{8}{3}}

s = 30

ScottTargetTestPrep · Answer

We can let the rate of Car Y = r and the rate of Car X = 1.5r. Recall that 2 hours and 40 minutes = 2 2/3 hours = 8/3 hours.

We can create the equation:

1.5r(8/3) = r(8/3) + 40

12r/3 = 8r/3 + 40

4r/3 = 40

4r = 120

r = 30

Skyline393 · Answer

Speed of Car Y = x => Speed of Car X = 1.5x (miles/h)
Distance = 40 miles 
Catch up time = Distance between X&Y/ Different speed between X&Y => 40/(1.5x - x) = 2h40mins = 8/3 hours (40mins = 2/3 hour)
=> x = 30 miles/hr

Jansaida · Answer

Using ratio approach to solve this problem

It's given that speed of X is 50% more than speed of Y---------> Speed of X =3/2 * Speed of Y

We can take speed of X=3k and Speed of Y=2K (I'm using K because I don't know the actual quantity)

X will cover 40 miles in 2 hours 40 minutes which means that the difference between X and Y of 40 miles is covered by X in 2 hours 40 minutes

Difference of X and Y covered by X (speed)= (40)/(8/3)= (40*3)/8 = 15 miles every hour-----------> Equation 1

Difference of X and Y = 3k-2k = K ---------------> Equation 2

Equating both of them we get

k=15 miles per hour.

Speed of Y= 2K = 2*15 mph= 30 miles per hour
Speed of X= 3*15 mph= 45 miles per hour.

Archit3110 · Answer

speed of y ; a
speed of x ; 1.5a
given time ; 2 hrs 40 mins ; 160 mins ; 160/60 ; 8/3 hrs

from given info we can say
1.5a*8/3 = 40+ 8*a/3
solve for a = 30 mph
IMO C

Archit3110 · Answer

speed of y = s
speed of x= 1.5s
relative speed = .5s
distance = 40 miles
time ; 160 mins ; 160/60 ; 8/3 hrs
40=8/3 * .5s
s= 30 mph
IMO C

dave13 · Answer

hi GMATPrepNow Brent

what is the reason that you attribute 40 miles to Y Car ? Car X still have to do more than 40 miles

I ask this question because i see other solutions in this thread, attributing 40 miles to car X as well

Or maybe it doesn`t matter

thanks

BrentGMATPrepNow · Answer

All that really matters is that we start with a 40-mile gap between the two cars.

However, since Car X is 40 miles west of Car Y, and since the cars are travelling east, we see that Car Y is originally 40 miles ahead of Car X. 
So, when the two cars are at the same position, Car X will have travelled 40 miles further than Car Y. 
To account for this (and create an equation) we need to add 40 miles to Car Y's travel distance.

Does that help?

Cheers,
Brent

KarishmaB · Answer

The questions uses relative speed. Both cars are going in the same direction (East) with X 40 miles behind Y. The ratio of their speeds is 3:2 so the difference between them is the speed of X relative to Y. This speed is what will decide the time X takes to overtake Y Distance between X and Y = 40 miles Time taken by X to overtake Y = 2 hr 40 mins = 8/3 hrs Speed of X relative to Y = 40/(8/3) = 15 mph 3 : 2 Diff on ratio scale = 1 which is actually 15. Hence the multiplier is 15 and their speeds are 45 mph (of X) and 30 mph (of Y). Answer (C) Check this video to know how to recognise relative speed questions: https://youtu.be/wrYxeZ2WsEM Check these videos to learn how to use ratios to do these calculations orally: https://youtu.be/5ODENGG5dvc https://youtu.be/7ASEIvxYPCM

yashx22 · Answer

Decided to plugin the answer choices for this one.
Starting from the middle, say speed of car Y is 30mph, so the speed of car X will be 45mph.

D = 40 miles
S = 45mph - 30mph = 15mph (relative speed)
T = 40/15 hours = 8/3 hours

Now 8/3 hours * 60 = 160 minutes = 120 minutes (2 hours) + 40 mins

bumpbot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club BumpBot:

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

This post was generated automatically.

Car X is 40 miles west of Car Y. Both cars are traveling east, and Car

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Problem Solving (PS) Questions

Car X is 40 miles west of Car Y. Both cars are traveling east, and Car

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards