Thanks a lot for the very detailed explanation — really appreciate you taking the time to break it down so clearly.
Your points about the weighting of the GPA and the quantitative expectations of MEcon definitely make sense.
To be honest, I was considering MEcon this year
precisely because I’m not planning to take the GRE right now. If I were taking a standardized test, I’d probably aim for something more quantitative like the MiQE/F. But with my apprenticeship, finding enough time to properly prepare is
extremely difficult, and applying in the last round — which is very competitive — wouldn’t leave me with the margin I’d need to get a strong score.
For context, my specialization of my master's is Corporate & Investment Banking, so I’m not sure how much that helps from MEcon’s perspective. My quantitative foundations mainly come from
classe prépa, so the math/stats rigor is there, but I understand the committee still likes to see a standardized benchmark to compare international applicants.
Between
GMAT and GRE, I’m still unsure which would be the better signal for HSG; I’ve seen mixed opinions, but most people seem to say the GRE Quant is slightly more aligned with what the MEcon admission team looks for, as you already said.
Given all this, I’m debating between applying now (before the 31st jan) without a test (or if i take it next week and get a very average score test), or waiting the last cycle to apply with a proper GRE score.
Thanks again for your insights — genuinely helpful!
dotsoftme
To be blunt: while the University of St. Gallen (HSG) technically makes the GRE
"optional" for the Master in Economics (MEcon), applying without it as an international student is a high-risk strategy that I strongly advise against.
Based on your profile and the HSG selection criteria, here is a hard look at where you stand.
1. The "Double Weighting" Trap
For the MEcon program, if you do not submit a GRE/GMAT score, the weighting of your
Average Grade is effectively doubled (from 25% to 50%).
- The Risk: A 3.5/4 GPA is solid, but in the hyper-competitive pool of HSG international applicants—many of whom come with 3.8+ GPAs—you lose your best chance to "offset" a less-than-perfect GPA.
- The Math: By not providing a GRE score, you are betting 50% of your admission on a single number. If the admissions committee views a 3.5 from your specific institution as just "good" rather than "elite," you have no secondary quantitative data point to prove your excellence.
2. Competitive Context: French MiM vs. MEcon
You are coming from a Master in Management (MiM) in France. While a Top 10 MiM is prestigious, the MEcon is a highly
quantitative economics degree.
- Academic Gap: HSG requires at least 60 ECTS in economics, math, and statistics. They will scrutinize your French "Classes Préparatoires" and MiM transcripts to ensure you have the rigor needed for their advanced econometrics courses.
- Why the GRE helps: A high Quantitative score on the GRE (aim for 163+) acts as a "bridge," proving to the committee that despite coming from a management background, you have the mathematical maturity to handle a pure Economics Master's.
3. Selection Criteria Breakdown
Your profile has strong "soft" assets, but the MEcon selection is heavily weighted toward hard metrics:
| Criterion | Weight | Your Status |
| Average Grade | 25% (or 50% w/o GRE) | 3.5/4 (Solid, but not "safe" on its own) |
| GRE / GMAT | 25% (or 0%) | Currently 0% (Missed opportunity for points) |
| Extracurricular / Work | 30% | Strong (Apprenticeship & Club President) |
| Motivation Letter | 10% | Strong potential (4 languages, international) |
| University / Curriculum | 10% | Strong (Top 10 French MiM) |
My Verdict: You Must Take the GRE
Your profile is excellent, but for an international student, applying without the GRE is like running a race with one hand tied behind your back. The "Law on Foreigners" in Switzerland limits the number of spots for non-Swiss applicants, making the international pool significantly more competitive.
Where to work hard:- Quantitative Prep: Focus 100% on the Quantitative Reasoning section of the GRE. For MEcon, this is the only section they explicitly state is "decisive."
- Writing Sample: Don't forget that MEcon requires a Writing Sample (3,000+ words). You must ensure this sample demonstrates economic analytical depth, not just management theory.