Hi ron34,
Premise 1: Federal regulations require that corporations use separate accounting firms for audit and non-audit
services, resulting in certain shortcomings faced by the corporations
Shortcomings: There are
only four (implying lack of variety) large international accounting firms based in the United
States
Premise 2: The CEO group makes a suggestion.
Suggestion: Break up the
EXISTING firms into smaller units
Purpose served by suggestion: Corporations will have more options for their accounting needs,
(albeit without acquiring any new firms) resulting in variety.
Now, let us analyze C:
Shortcomings: School district superintendent writes a letter to the publisher or his district’s textbooks complaining
about lack of variety (resulting perhaps due to monotony of textual content, as indicated by purpose
of suggestion made further)
Suggestion: Break the
EXISTING content iin textbooks under new headers.
Purpose served: To address the shortcomings (lack of variety), resulting in renewed focus towards desired content in accordance with level of emphasis w.r.t. their corporate structure,
(albeit without addition of anything new to the original text content).In conclusion, the CEO’s want to break up the EXISTING four firms into smaller units, which will inevitably lead to a greater number of TOTAL accounting firms, a line of reasoning quite similar to the one echoed in option C.