Dr. Jones: The new technology dubbed “telemedicine” will provide sustained improvement in at least rural patient care since it allows rural physicians to televise medical examinations to specialists who live at great distances—specialists who will thus be able to provide advice the rural patient would otherwise not receive.
Dr. Carabella: Not so. Telemedicine might help rural patient care initially. However, small hospitals will soon realize that they can minimize expenses by replacing physicians with technicians who can use telemedicine to transmit examinations to large medical centers, resulting in fewer patients being able to receive traditional, direct medical examinations. Eventually, it will be the rare individual who ever gets truly personal attention. Hence, rural as well as urban patient care will suffer.
Dr. Carabella uses which one of the following strategies in responding to Dr. Jones?
(A) listing a set of considerations to show that a prescribed treatment that seems to be benefiting a patient in fact
harms that patient - WRONG. Slight language change it just ruins the choice. Nowhere it is said the patient would be harmed.
(B) describing the application of the technology discussed by Dr. Jones as one step that initiates a process that
leads to an undesirable end - CORRECT. What may not happen is what that strategy is.
(C) citing evidence that
Dr. Jones lacks the professional training to judge the case at issue - WRONG. Not the case/
(D)
invoking medical statistics that cast doubt on the premises used in Dr. Jones’s argument - WRONG. NO medical statistics used.
(E) providing grounds for
dismissing Dr. Jones’s interpretation of a key term in medical technology - WRONG. Not at all.
Answer B.