Frank28
Zoologist: Horseflies are attracted to horizontally polarized light, which reflects off large, dark animals that they bite. This may explain why zebras evolved vertical stripes -- the stripes cancel the horizontal polarization of light and thus make zebras less attractive to horseflies.
In order to assess the plausibility of the zoologist's hypothesis, it would be most helpful to know whether
Time Taken: 1 min 55 seconds |
Question Type: Evaluate the Argument
1. Translating the technical aspect of polarization to simple language, consider that when light falls on a surface with a single color it becomes visible to horseflies, whereas when stripes come into picture the light reaches in very low quantity to houseflies.
2. This reduction in the amount of light makes Zebras less attractive to horseflies. So the hypothesis is that the stripes keep the horseflies away from the Zebras
3. The correct answer will be two-way a. Yes, the stripes make the Zebras less attractive to horseflies and b. No, the stripes do not make the Zebras less attractive to horseflies
First, the correct option:
E. zebras' vertical stripes provide camouflage protection against certain large predators potentially very dangerous to zebrasThis is in line with our pre-thinking
a. Yes, the stripes provide protection against large predators - In that case the hypothesis falls apart as the stripes are meant for keep horseflies away from Zebras
b. No, the stripes do not provide protection against large predators - In that case the hypothesis does apply
A. any insects other than horseflies are attracted to horizontally polarized lightWe are concerned about the protection of Zebras from horseflies and are not concerned about other insects
B. the vertical stripes on zebras make it easier for any insects other than horseflies to see themAgain, same as explanation for A
C. animals that horseflies commonly bite have evolved other means of reducing the impact an frequency of those bitesWe are concerned with the evolution of Zebra stripes and the protection they provide from horseflies. The other animals that horseflies bite is not relevant to the argument at hand
D. any biting insects other than horseflies are strongly attracted to zebrasAgain, same as explanation for A
Ans.
E