Bunuel
Educator: Scholars are concerned that the increasing popularity of online universities and low-residency degree programs will render the classroom experience obscure. They object to this trend, saying that online courses do not offer the level of collaboration and support that the traditional classroom does. At Plymouth Online, however, we offer a fully interactive experience with web video, web-based collaboration software, online chat, and video conferencing sessions. It is therefore possible to join our online university and experience a very close approximation of the in-classroom experience, and in some situations, the experience is a richer and more satisfying one.
The educator’s argument proceeds by
(A) referring to a scholarly authority to challenge a widely held belief
(B) questioning the accuracy of evidence given in support of an opposing position
(C) offering a counterexample to a prevalent belief among experts in the field
(D) proposing an alternative sociological explanation for a pedagogical practice
(E) making a distinction between instructional approaches
Scholars’ argument: Online universities will render the classroom experience obscure. This is not good because online courses do not offer the level of collaboration and support that the traditional classroom does.
Educator’s argument: At Plymouth Online, we offer a fully interactive experience with web video etc. It is therefore possible to join our online university and experience a very close approximation of the in-classroom experience, and in some situations, the experience is a richer and more satisfying one.
Scholar and Educator have opposing views.
Scholar believes that the online programs cannot replace classroom experience well.
Educator believes that Plymouth online can suitably replace classrooms.
The educator counters the scholars’ argument by giving the example of Plymouth online and how it provides similar level of collaboration as does a traditional classroom.
The educator’s argument proceeds by
(A) Referring to a scholarly authority to challenge a widely held beliefHe does not refer to any scholarly authority.
(B) Questioning the accuracy of evidence given in support of an opposing positionThe scholar gives no evidence in support of his argument so the educator does not question the accuracy of evidence.
(C) Offering a counterexample to a prevalent belief among experts in the fieldYes, the educator gives a counter example (of Plymouth online), an example that is counter to a prevalent belief among experts (prevalent belief is that online courses do not offer the level of collaboration and support that the traditional classroom does)
(D) Proposing an alternative sociological explanation for a pedagogical practiceThere is no alternative sociological explanation given.
(E) Making a distinction between instructional approachesThe educator doesn’t make a distinction between approaches. He gives a counterexample to the view among scholars.
Answer (C) Method Questions are discussed here:
https://youtu.be/uA5aXAZI1Z8