This semester Professor Popkin will commute to Montreal by plane, leav

Question

This semester Professor Popkin will commute to Montreal by plane, leaving every Tuesday and returning to Toronto every Friday. She instructs her travel agent to schedule for her one round-trip that departs from Toronto on the first Tuesday and returns to Toronto on the last Friday of the semester and additional round-trips that depart from and return to Montreal for each weekly commute in between.

Which one of the following, if true, most helps to explain Professor Popkin’s instructions to her travel agent regarding the grouping of her flights into round-trips?

(A) Professor Popkin’s round-trip tickets are least expensive if each trip is scheduled so that at least one Saturday night intervenes between the departing flight and the returning flight.

(B) A ticket for a round-trip in which the departing flight and the returning flight are separated by several months will cost Professor Popkin more than a ticket for a round-trip in which they are separated by less than one week.

(C) Professor Popkin will be eligible to travel in the first-class section of the plane at no extra charge after she has completed a specified number of round-trips.

(D) If all Professor Popkin’s tickets are paid for at one time, she will be eligible for a frequent traveler discount.

(E) In order for Professor Popkin to receive the lowest possible airfare, each of her roundtrips must be paid for at least seven days in advance of the departing flight.

zhanbo · Answer

Prof. Popkin's round-trip tickets schedule is as follows:
The first round-trip span the whole semester: Leave Toronto on 1st Tuesday and Leave Montreal on the last Friday.
The second round-trip ticket: Leave Montreal on 1st Friday and Leave Toronto on 2nd Tuesday.
And so on.

Which answer choice can explain the rationale behind such arrangement (instead of an alternative plan: simply purchasing one round-trip ticket for one week, leaving Toronto on Tuesdays and Leaving Montreal on Fridays)?

(A) By choosing this schedule, all Professor Popkin’s round-trip tickets include one (or more, for the very first ticket)Saturday night stay between two segments. Keep.

(B) If true, Professor Popkin should refrain from making such arrangement because the very first round-trip ticket is separated by several months. It cannot justify professor's plan.

(C) It has mostly neutral impact on either Professor's plan or the alternative plan. By not completing the first round trip flight in the first week, Professor Popkin's eligibility is actually pushed back by a week. So, it cannot provide support.

(D) It has no impact on either plan.

(E) It has no impact on either plan.

The answer is  (A) .

desertEagle · Answer

Argument: 
Popkin orders her travel agents to book flight between montreal and Toronto on Friday and Tuesday in a specified order

Question type 
Why this order?

(A) Professor Popkin’s round-trip tickets are least expensive if each trip is scheduled so that at least one Saturday night intervenes between the departing flight and the returning flight. --->  So she wants it to be least expensive -->  CORRECT

(B) A ticket for a round-trip in which the departing flight and the returning flight are separated by several months will cost Professor Popkin more than a ticket for a round-trip in which they are separated by less than one week. -->  If this were the case then why would she order one return ticket on first Tuesday and come back on last Friday. This will cost more money. ---> Incorrect

(C) Professor Popkin will be eligible to travel in the first-class section of the plane at no extra charge after she has completed a specified number of round-trips.-->  number of roundtrips are not an issue here as whatever order she picks up, if she satisfies the criteria, she will get first class section at no extra charge ---> Incorrect

(D) If all Professor Popkin’s tickets are paid for at one time, she will be eligible for a frequent traveler discount. -->  One time payment is not discussed ---> Incorrect

(E) In order for Professor Popkin to receive the lowest possible airfare, each of her roundtrips must be paid for at least seven days in advance of the departing flight. -->  Payment is not discussed ---> Incorrect

sayan640 · Answer

KarishmaB   MartyMurray  Can you please break this question down for me ?
Not able to understand the schedule . Struggling with this question.

Posted from my mobile device

MartyMurray · Answer

This semester Professor Popkin will commute to Montreal by plane, leaving every Tuesday and returning to Toronto every Friday. She instructs her travel agent to schedule for her one round-trip that departs from Toronto on the first Tuesday and returns to Toronto on the last Friday of the semester and additional round-trips that depart from and return to Montreal for each weekly commute in between.

We see that this way of booking flights will have the following result:

The first round trip, which "departs from Toronto on the first Tuesday and returns to Toronto on the last Friday of the semester," will involve flights that are months apart.

Then, all the other round trips will not appear to be from Toronto to Montreal and back to Toronto. Rather, they will appear to depart from Montreal on Friday and return to Montreal on Tuesday. So, they will appear to be from Montreal to Toronto and back to Toronto.

Which one of the following, if true, most helps to explain Professor Popkin’s instructions to her travel agent regarding the grouping of her flights into round-trips?

(A) Professor Popkin’s round-trip tickets are least expensive if each trip is scheduled so that at least one Saturday night intervenes between the departing flight and the returning flight.

This choice matches how the flights are booked.

The first round trip booked will have multiple Saturday nights during the semester between the flight from Toronto to Montreal and the flight back from Montreal to Toronto.

Then, since the other trips will be from Montreal to Toronto on Friday and then from Toronto to Montreal on Tuesday, they will all have Saturdays between the flights that make up the round trips.

So, through booking the flights in this way, the tickets will be the least expensive.

Keep.

(B) A ticket for a round-trip in which the departing flight and the returning flight are separated by several months will cost Professor Popkin more than a ticket for a round-trip in which they are separated by less than one week.

This choice doesn't fit the instructions. After all, if the round trips were booked normally, each would have occurred in under a week, the first flight being on a Tuesday and the flight back on a Friday.

Also, the first trip booked, the one that is as if it's to be taken at the beginning and end of the semester would involve a departing flight and a returning flight separated by months and thus costing more than it would have if booked normally.

Eliminate.

(C) Professor Popkin will be eligible to travel in the first-class section of the plane at no extra charge after she has completed a specified number of round-trips.

This choice doesn't fit the instructions since the professor would have been eligible to travel in the first-class section sooner if the first flight to Montreal had not been paired with a flight back to Toronto at the end of the semester.

Eliminate.

(D) If all Professor Popkin’s tickets are paid for at one time, she will be eligible for a frequent traveler discount.

The elaborate instructions are not necessary for taking advantage of this discount since the tickets can be paid for at one time regardless of how the trips are set up.

Eliminate.

(E) In order for Professor Popkin to receive the lowest possible airfare, each of her roundtrips must be paid for at least seven days in advance of the departing flight.

The elaborate instructions are not necessary for taking advantage of the lowest airfare since the tickets can be paid for at least seven days in advance of the departing flight regardless of how the trips are set up.

Eliminate.

Correct answer:  A

VerbalBot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club VerbalBot: 

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

 This post was generated automatically.

This semester Professor Popkin will commute to Montreal by plane, leav

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Critical Reasoning (CR) Questions

This semester Professor Popkin will commute to Montreal by plane, leav

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards