Conclusion: Confucian govt., however virtuous and moral, remained undemocratic.
Scope: How/Why conclusion will hold true?
A. Not every citizen participated in the Imperial examination system and hence government officers consequently chosen did not represent ‘voice of people’.
We don’t know whether “Voice of people” is democracy or not.
B. Ideas such as imperial examination system are central to the philosophy of democracy.
This weakens the conclusion stated.
C. Confucian governments are not as effective as democratic governments.
It is talking about the effectiveness of the government. Our concern is related to whether the confucian govt. is democratic or not.
D. Passing a morality exam leads to a non-democratic government.
This choice strengthens the conclusion. But the negated statement “ Passing a morality exam did not leads to a non democratic government” But what about if the govt. is already non democratic. This choice has no bearing on the conclusion and thus a wrong answer.
E. It is not possible for a government to maintain “nobility of virtue” while ensuring a fair representation of the views of entire cross section of society
The choice strengthens the conclusion by stating that by maintaining the “nobility of virtue” will not insure fair representation. By negating this choice, it breaks down the conclusion.
The correct answer is Choice E.