Bunuel
World War II had a profound effect on the growth of nascent businesses. The Acme Packaging Company netted only $10,000 in the year before the war. By 1948, it was earning almost 10 times that figure.
The argument above depends upon which of the following assumptions.
A. Acme's growth rate is representative of that of other nascent businesses.
B. An annual profit of $10,000 is not especially high.
C. Wars inevitably stimulate a nation's economy.
D. Rapid growth for nascent businesses is especially desirable.
E. Acme is not characterized by responsible, far-sighted managers.
Let me try to explain my logic.
So this is a Causal Relationship CR question.
Here,
World War II had a profound effect on the growth of nascent businesses.-- THIS IS THE CONCLUSION.
SO ......
WW2 ------> Growth on Nascent Businesses The Acme Packaging Company netted only $10,000 in the year before the war. By 1948, it was earning almost 10 times that figure.-- THIS part is just giving support to the above Conclusion that WW2 lead to the growth in Acme Packaging company which represents Nascent Business. ( I dont know what Nascent means

)
Quote:
Now , our main focus should be on
WW2 ------> Growth on Nascent Businesses what if there is some other circumstance which lead to the increase in revenue of APC from 10,000 before war to almost 100,000 after war??
What if
production technology improved---> cost per product decreased---> lead to increase in sales/revenue.So I am looking for an answer choice which says that ...
Hello !!! My dear child .... there were/was no other circumstance/s which lead to increase in Revenue.
....WW2 was the reason for increase in revenue of ACP.Lets look at CHOICE E.
Quote:
E. Acme is not characterized by responsible, far-sighted managers.
So , this option hints us to think in the direction that " It was not the farsightedness of the responsbile managers which lead to the increase in revenue"
ie this option removes our doubt of the presence of any other circumstance which lead to the increase in revenue.
Hence I went with E.
Lets wait for OA .
Regards