John and Ed work for the same Sales Company. John receives a $600 basi

Question

John and Ed work for the same Sales Company. John receives a $600 basic salary plus 20 percent of any profit he realizes for the company in excess of $5,000, while Ed receives an $800 basic salary in addition to 40 percent of any profit he realizes for the company only if the total profit he realizes is greater than $8,000, otherwise he receives a flat salary of $1,000. For what amount of profit will both John and Ed earn the same amount?

A. $1,000
B. $1,200
C. $2,400
D. $6,000
E. $7,000

A. $1,000
B. $1,200
C. $2,400
D. $6,000
E. $7,000

pushpitkc · Answer

John's salary is 600$ + 20% of the profit from sales > $5000
Ed's salary is 800$ + 40% of the profit from sales > $8000 (Else, he receives a flat salary of $1000)

Since the basic salary of John is 600$ and he receives 20% over 5000$ in profit,
in order to make the earnings equal,  0.2*(x-5000) + 600 = 1000 
 The reason Ed's earning will not be greater than the flat rate of $1000 is 
because Ed earns 40% of the sales, whereas John earns only 20% of the sales

Simplifying this further, we get  0.2*(x-5000) = 400  ->  x-5000 = 2000  ->  x = 7000

Therefore, at  7000(Option E)  as the common profit, John and Ed earn the same amount.

luffy_ueki · Answer

Based on the problem stmt:
J = 600 + 20%(P-5000) where P is the profit, and J is the salary recieved by John

E = 800 + 40% of P (if P >8000)
else E=1000

lets see if for any value of P we can have J = E .. on solving we get P=7000

GMATGuruNY · Answer

We can PLUG IN THE ANSWERS, which represent the amount of profit.

Since Ed earns a flat salary of $1000 if the amount of profit does not exceed $8000 -- and all of the answer choices are less than 8000 -- Ed's earnings = $1000. 
Since John and Ed must earn the same amount, John must also earn $1000.

John earns a $600 base salary plus 20% of any profit in excess of $5000. 
Thus, for John to earn $1000, the correct answer must be greater than 5000. 
Eliminate A, B and C. 
When the correct answer is plugged in, the amount of profit in excess of $5000 will yield John an additional $400 on top of his $600 base salary, bringing his total earnings to $1000.

D: 6000, implying $1000 profit in excess of $5000 
Additional earnings for John = 20% of $1000 = 200. 
Too small. 
Eliminate D.

E

E: 7000, implying $2000 profit in excess of $5000 
Additional earnings for John = 20% of $2000 = 400. 
Success!

adstudy · Answer

According to question -

John's earning => 600 + 20% (P - 5000) ------  (1) 
where P is the amount company earned

Ed's earning => 800 + 40% (P) 
where P is the amount company earned
----------------------------
Now if P < 8000 then
Ed's earning => 1000 ------  (2)

if P>8000
Ed's earning => 800 + 40% (Q) ------  (3)

Now question says for what profit (P) will they earn the same amount i.e John's earning = Ed's earning

Now if we look at the options, we see that P is less than 8000, therefore Ed's earning will be 1000 (From  (2) )

Therefore using  (1) and (2)

600 + 20% (P - 5000) = 1000

On solving this we get P = 7000

Hence E

JeffTargetTestPrep · Answer

Notice that Ed earns a higher basic salary and a higher percentage of the profit (if the profit is over $8000) than John. Therefore, there is no way John will earn the same amount as Ed unless the profit is not over $8000. In that case, Ed will only receive a flat salary of $1,000. Therefore, we can create the equation:

600 + 0.2(P - 5000) = 1000

0.2P - 1000 = 400

0.2P = 1400

P = 1400/0.2 = 14000/2 = 7000

Answer: E

800Dreamer · Answer

Many of you might be thinking that for Ed we need to check 2 cases. One less than and one greater than 8000.
But no.
See carefully the options. None is >8000.
So case 2 gone.
Only case is left ---> 0.2∗(x−5000)+600=1000

x=7000.

Solved in a minute.

bumpbot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club BumpBot: 

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

 This post was generated automatically.

John and Ed work for the same Sales Company. John receives a $600 basi

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

GMAT Problem Solving (PS) Questions

John and Ed work for the same Sales Company. John receives a $600 basi

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia