If x and y are integers, is (x−1)y?

Question

If x and y are integers, is (x−1)>y?

(1) x is a positive multiple of y
(2) x/y > 1

akkiankurgupta · Answer

I recently came across this question and wasn't sure if the answer mentioned in the source was correct. I will appreciate if someone can explain why this answer is correct.

If x and y are integers, is x > y ?

1. x is a positive multiple of y
2. xy > 1

mikemcgarry · Answer

Dear akkiankurgupta , I'm happy to help. I actually disagree with the OA. The reason I disagree is that any integer is a multiple of itself. For example, 3 is a multiple of 3; in fact, 3 is a positive multiple of 3. Therefore, we could have x = y = 3, and both statements would be true by x would not be greater than y --- a "no" answer to the prompt. Of course x = 6 and y = 3 also work, and produce a "yes" answer. I'm not sure the authors considered this technicality ---- including this, the answer would be (E) . Even disregarding this technicality, there's something fishy about statement #1 --- by the statement " x is a positive multiple of y ", do we mean (a) that x is a positive integer that also happens to be a multiple of y, in which cases x = +6 and y = -3 would be possible. or (b) that x is y times some positive integer, in which cases x = -6 and y = -2 Oddly enough, neither of these interpretations, nor the inclusion or exclusion of the technicality above, produce an answer of (C). Something is funny here. Those are my thoughts. Let me know if you have any further questions. Mike :-)

mikemcgarry · Answer

Dear guerrero25 , In your understanding, or in the source, what exactly does " positive multiple " mean? In my mind, the statement " x is a positive multiple of y " lends itself to two very different interpretations: (1) x is a positive number and also happens to be a multiple of y; in this case, we could have x = +10 and y = -5 OR (b) x equals y times some positive integer; in this case, we could have x = -10 and y = -5 Of course, either interpretation would be correct with the OA in this question, because x = 15 and y = 3 satisfy both statements and give a "yes" answer to the prompt, and x = 2 and y = 1 satisfy both statements and give a "no" answer to the prompt. Does all this make sense? Mike :-)

guerrero25 · Answer

Here is the OE .

Solution: E. This is a great opportunity to play devil's advocate, picking numbers to get "yes" and "no" answers using both statements.

For statement 1, x could be 10 and y could be 1, giving you "yes". But it could also be 1 and 1, so you could get the answer "no".

For statement 2, again x could be 10 and y could be 1, giving you "yes". But you could also have the same with negative numbers, -10 and -1, giving you "no".

The statements together may look to be sufficient (again, 10 and 1 give you "yes"). But 2 and 1 also work, which would make x-1 equal to y, not greater. So because you can still get "no" and "yes", the correct answer is E.

GGMAT760 · Answer

Hi 
I dont understand how C is wrong answer here?
2 is not multiple of 1 so how can we use 2 and 1 while combining two statements?
What I thought, when we combine both statements then numbers could be X=4 (multiple of 2) Y=2 , 4/2 is greater than 1 so answer comes yes.
The same way all multiples give same "yes" answer. We cannt use X=2, Y=2 since it does not satisfy statement 2. 
Please explain ..how E answer is right not C...

Thanks in advance
Komal

Bunuel · Answer

An integer  a  is a multiple of an integer  b  means that  \frac{a}{b}=integer .

Thus since 2/1=2=integer, then 2 IS a multiple of 1. By the way, any integer is a multiple of 1, since 1 is a factor of every integer.

Also on the GMAT when we are told that  a  is divisible by  b  (or which is the same: " a  is a multiple of  b ", or " b  is a factor of  a "), we can say that: 
1.  a  is an integer;
2.  b  is an integer;
3.  \frac{a}{b}=integer .

jlgdr · Answer

Is x>y+1? Statement 1 X is a multiple of y If y=1 and x=1 answer is NO If y=1 and x=3 answer is YES Insufficient Statement 2 x-y / y >0 If y>0 then x>y>0 If y<0 then x

MathRevolution · Answer

Forget conventional ways of solving math questions. In DS, Variable approach is the easiest and quickest way to find the answer without actually solving the problem. Remember equal number of variables and independent equations ensures a solution. If x and y are integers, is (x−1)>y? (1) x is a positive multiple of y (2) x/y > 1 In the original condition there are 2 variables (x,y) and we need 2 equations to match the number of variables and equations. Since there is 1 each in 1) and 2), C has high probability of being the answer. Using both 1) & 2) together (to save time), the answer is no if x=2, y=1, while the answer is yes if x=4, y=1 yes. Therefore the conditions are not sufficient. The answer is E. Normally in case of DS inequality problems, 1) a>b>c --> a>b, b>c, a>c 2) a>b --> a+x>b+x and a-x>b-x 3) a>b and c>d --> a+c>b+d 4) a>0 --> 2a>0, a<0 --> 2a a-1

Madhavi1990 · Answer

Narrow miss. Almost picked A. But there is always the 'language' red flag.
St 1: x is a positive multiple of y.
I immediately thought y is negative. In that case, asper number line; x - 1> y (on the left of zero). But what if y is positive? Then I am not sure, cause no values are given.

St 2:x/y> 1 so x> y. But is x -1> y? I am not sure again.

1) + 2) = ultimately I am not clear about the direction of x and y: which one is left of zero or right; or are both in the same direction. So cannot conclude x-1>y

So picked E as no particular answer was sufficient, even after combining.

bumpbot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club BumpBot: 

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

 This post was generated automatically.

If x and y are integers, is (x−1)>y?

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Data Sufficiency (DS) Questions

If x and y are integers, is (x−1)>y?

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards