TBT
Is \(xy > 0\) ?
(1) \(x-y=2\)
(2)\( (\frac{x}{y}) < 1\)
QuestionIs \(xy > 0\), in other words, we need to find whether x and y have the same sign (are they on the same side of zero) ?
Statement 1(1) \(x-y=2\)
Case 1: x and y can be on the same side of zero.
----------
y ----------
x ----------- 0 --------------
y -----------------
x ----------
Ex:
y = 2 ; x = 4
y = -4 ; x = -2
In both cases, Is \(xy > 0\) - Yes !
Case 2: x and y can be on the opposite side of zero.
--------- y ------- 0 -------- x --------
Ex: x = 1 and y = -1
Is \(xy > 0\) - No !
The statement is not sufficient.
We can eliminate A and D.
Statement 2(2)\( (\frac{x}{y}) < 1\)
Case 1: x and y can be on the same side of zero.
----------
y ----------
x ----------- 0 --------------
Ex:
y = -4 ; x = -2
Is \(xy > 0\) - Yes !
Case 2: x and y can be on the opposite side of zero.
--------- y ------- 0 -------- x --------
Ex: x = 1 and y = -1
Is \(xy > 0\) - No !
The statement is not sufficient.
Eliminate B
CombinedThe statements combined don't help either as both cases mentioned in statement 2 is applicable for statement 1.
Option EP.S = The indicated answer is incorrect. Should be E and not C.