From the start to the end of the trading day on Monday, the price of a stock increased by x percent. Then, from the start to the end of the trading day on Tuesday, the price decreased by y percent. Was the price greater at the end of the trading day on Tuesday than at the start of the trading day on Monday?
(1) x > yGiven this information, x and y could be far apart or close together.
If they are far apart, the percentage increase will be much larger than the percentage decrease. In such cases, the price will be higher at the end of the day Tuesday than it was at the start of the day Monday.
Example: x = 100, y = 1, Starting Price = 100
100 -> 200 -> 198
Yes, greater at the end of the day on Tuesday.
If they are close together, the percentage increase will be similar to the the percentage decrease but the decrease will be from a higher base. So, the percentage decrease will have a greater effect. In such cases, the price will be lower at the end of the day Tuesday than it was at the start of the day Monday.
Example: x = 100, y = 90, Starting Price = 100
100 -> 200 -> 20
No, not greater at the end of the day on Tuesday.
Insufficient.
(2) x = 2yIn this case, we know the relative sizes of x and y, but there are still multiple possible outcomes.
If x < 100, then y < 50, and the price increase will be larger than the price decrease.
Example: x = 40, y = 20, Starting Price = 100
100 -> 140 -> 112
Yes, greater at the end of the day on Tuesday.
If x = 100, then y = 50, and the price increase will be the same as the price decrease.
Example: x = 100, y = 50, Starting Price = 100
100 -> 200 -> 100
No, not greater at the end of the day on Tuesday.
If x > 100, then y > 50, and the price increase will be smaller than the price decrease.
Example: x = 200, y = 100, Starting Price = 100
100 -> 300 -> 0
No, not greater at the end of the day on Tuesday.
Insufficient.
(1) and (2) combinedStatement (2) indicates that statement (1) is also true. So, combining the statements doesn't make any difference.
Insufficient.
Correct answer: E