In 2001, Joe paid 5.1 percent of his income in taxes. In 2002, did Joe pay less than 5.1 percent of his income in taxes?
(1) From 2001 to 2002, Joe’s income increased by 10 percent.
(2) Taxes paid in 2002 are 3.4 percent of Joe’s income in 2001.
Let Joe's income in the year 2001 be I1, and that in 2002 be I2.
In 2001, amount paid in taxes = 0.051*Income (5.1% of income)
We need to determine if Joey paid less than 5.1% of his income in taxes in 2002.
Now, let's look at each statement individually and then at both of them together (if required):
Statement 1: From 2001 to 2002, Joe’s income increased by 10 percent.
Given: I2 = 1.1*I1
However, we do not have any information about the amount of taxes paid by Joe in 2002. Hence, Statement 1 is clearly insufficent alone.
Now, let's take a look at Statement 2 closely:
Statement 2: Taxes paid in 2002 are 3.4 percent of Joe’s income in 2001.
Given: Tax paid in 2002 = 3.4% * I1 = 0.034* I1
However, as we do not have any information about Joe's income in 2001, we cannot determine the answer uniquely. Hence, Statement 2 is insufficient alone as well.
Now, let's look at the combination of both the statements:
I2 = 1.1*I1
Tax paid in 2002 = 0.034* I1
Thus, the percentage of income paid in taxes in the year 2002 = (0.034*I1) / (1.1*I1) * 100 = 3.09%
Hence, the correct answer is
Option C - BOTH statements TOGETHER are sufficient, but NEITHER statement ALONE is sufficient.
Hope this helps!