ExpertsGlobal5
Murtaugh Dynamics and O.R.E Machinery are sister firms. Rounded to the nearest thousand, what was the combined 2022-2023 revenue for the two firms?
(1) Rounded to the nearest thousand, the 2022-2023 revenues for Murtaugh Dynamics and O.R.E Machinery were $200,000 and $150,000 respectively.
(2) The exact revenue figures for Murtaugh Dynamics and O.R.E Machinery were each within 0.4% of the rounded figures.
Explanation: Let the exact revenue for Murtaugh Dynamics in 2022-2023 be M.
Let the exact revenue for O.R.E Machinery in 2022-2023 be O.
The combined 2022-2023 exact revenue for the two firms = M + O
We need to find whether the value of M + O rounded to the nearest thousand can be determined. Statement (1) Rounded to the nearest thousand the 2022-2023 revenue for Murtaugh Dynamics = $200,000
This implies that 199,500 < M < 200,500 (Equation I)
Rounded to the nearest thousand the 2022-2023 revenue for O.R.E Machinery = $150,000
This implies that 149,500 < O < 150,500 (Equation I)
Adding Equations I and II,
199,500 + 149,500 < M + O < 200,500 + 150,500
349,000 < M + O < 351,000 Possibility 1: If M + O = 349,001, then M + O rounded to the nearest thousand = 349,000.
Possibility 2: If M + O = 350,999, then M + O rounded to the nearest thousand = 351,000.
It is NOT possible to determine the value of M + O rounded to the nearest thousand.
Hence, Statement (1) is insufficient. Statement (2) The exact revenue figures for Murtaugh Dynamics and O.R.E Machinery were each within 0.4% of the rounded figures.
Since
no information is provided regarding the rounded revenue figures, it is NOT possible to determine the value of M + O rounded to the nearest thousand.
Hence, Statement (2) is insufficient. As Statement (1) alone as well as Statement (2) alone is insufficient to answer the question, we need to now combine the two statements.
Statement (1) and Statement (2) combined The two statements combined give us the following equations:
200,000 – 0.4% of 200,000 < M < 200,000 + 0.4% of 200,000
200,000 – 800 < M < 200,000 + 800 (Equation III)
Similarly,
150,000 – 0.4% of 150,000 < O < 150,000 + 0.4% of 150,000
150,000 – 600 < O < 150,000 + 600 (Equation IV)
Adding Equations III and IV,
200,000 – 800 + 150,000 – 600 < M + O < 200,000 + 800 + 150,000 + 600
350,000 – 1,400 < M + O < 350,000 + 1,400 Possibility 1: If M + O = 350,000 – 1,001, then M + O rounded to the nearest thousand will be less than 350,000.
Possibility 2: If M + O = 350,000 + 1,001,
then M + O rounded to the nearest thousand will be more than 350,000.
It is NOT possible to determine the value of M + O rounded to the nearest thousand.
Hence, Statement (1) and Statement (2) combined are insufficient. E is the correct answer choice.