RonPurewal
A motorized boat traveled 30 miles directly against a current of
c miles per hour, and then returned 30 miles in the direction of the current, in a total of 8 hours. If the boat traveled the entire round trip at the same constant speed
relative to the water, what is the value of
c?
(1) The boat traveled at a constant speed of 4c miles per hour relative to the water.
(2) The boat traveled at a constant speed of 8 miles per hour relative to the water.
Official Explanation:Statement 1 alone:If the boat’s speed relative to the water is 4c miles per hour, then its actual travel speed for the first leg of the round trip (
against a current of
c miles
per hour) is 4c – c = 3c miles per hour, and its actual travel speed for the second leg of the round trip (
with a current of
c miles per hour) is 4c + c =
5c miles per hour.
The time taken for the first leg of the trip, therefore, is = \(\frac{30 \ mi}{3c \ mi/hr}=\frac{10}{c}\) hr,
and the time taken for the second leg of the trip is = \(\frac{30 \ mi}{5c \ mi/hr}=\frac{6}{c}\) hr .
Since the total duration of the journey was 8 hours, we can write
\(\frac{10}{c} + \frac{6}{c}=8\)
\(\frac{16}{c}=8\)
which can be solved for the unique value c = 2, so statement 1 alone is sufficient.
Statement 2 alone:If the boat’s speed relative to the water is 8 miles per hour, then its actual travel speed for the first leg of the round trip (
against a current of
c miles per hour) is (8 – c) miles per hour, and its actual travel speed for the second leg of the round trip (
with a current of
c miles per hour) is (8 + c) miles per hour.
The
time taken for the first leg of the trip, therefore, is = \(\frac{30 \ mi}{(8 + c) \ mi/hr}=\frac{30}{8 + c}\) hr, and the time taken for the second leg of the trip is \(\frac{30 \ mi}{(8 - c) \ mi/hr}=\frac{30}{8 - c}\).
Since the total duration of the journey was 8 hours, we can write
\(\frac{30}{8 + c} + \frac{30}{8 - c}=8\)
Multiply both sides by the common denominator (8 + c)(8 – c) to give
\(30(8 – c) + 30(8 – c)=8(8 + c)(8 – c)\)
\(60=64-c^2\)
which can be solved for the unique positive value c = 2 (
c cannot be negative, as that would contradict the basic meanings of “with” and “against” the current), so statement 2 alone is also sufficient.
The answer is D.