This is a beautifully constructed Data Sufficiency question — it looks intimidating because of the polynomial, but it's actually testing a clean concept once you strip it down.
Key concept being tested: Behavior of polynomials / whether a cubic function has a real root, combined with DS sufficiency logic
Restating the question: R = xi^3 + yi^2 + z, where i > 0. Can R equal 0 for some positive value of i?
Before touching the statements, think about what determines whether this polynomial can hit zero. It's a function of i, with coefficients x, y, z. The question is essentially: does the curve cross the x-axis for some i > 0?
Statement (1): x > y > z
This tells us the relative sizes of x, y, and z, but says nothing about their signs. For example:
- x=3, y=2, z=1 → R = 3i^3 + 2i^2 + 1. Since all terms are positive for i > 0, R > 0 always. No root.
- x=1, y=0, z=−2 → This satisfies x > y > z (1 > 0 > −2), and here R = i^3 − 2 = 0 when i = cube root of 2. Root exists.
Two different answers → Statement (1) is NOT sufficient.
Statement (2): x > 0
Again, tells us one coefficient is positive but nothing else. For example:
- x=1, y=1, z=1 → R = i^3 + i^2 + 1 > 0 for all positive i. No root.
- x=1, y=0, z=−5 → R = i^3 − 5 = 0 when i = cube root of 5. Root exists.
Two different answers → Statement (2) is NOT sufficient.
Combined: Even knowing x > y > z AND x > 0, we still can't determine the sign of z or whether R crosses zero. The examples from Statement (1) above (where x=3, y=2, z=1 gives no root and x=1, y=0, z=−2 gives a root) both satisfy x > 0 as well.
Combined statements are NOT sufficient.
Answer: E
Common trap: Students see a cubic polynomial and assume it must cross zero somewhere — because odd-degree polynomials always have at least one real root over all reals. But the domain here is restricted to i > 0, so you can't apply that general rule. The function might never reach zero on the positive side.
Takeaway: In Data Sufficiency, always check whether the stated domain restriction changes the behavior of a function before assuming general mathematical rules apply.