Jane, Chen and Boris start together to travel the same way

Question

Jane, Chen and Boris start together to travel the same way around a circular path of 20 kms. Their speeds are 4, 5 and 1/2, and 8 kms per hour respectively. When will they meet at the starting point? 

(A) 40 hours 

(B) 12 hours 

(C) 11 hours 

(D) 44 hours 

(E) 200/11 hours 

plz explain your answer. thanks.

buffetfollower · Answer

for them to meet at the starting point after some hours, they all should have travelled a distance which is a multiple of 20.

checking each of the answers,

(A) 40 hours
distances travelled by each of them are 160, 220, 320(40*4, 40*5.5, 40*8)

(B) 12 hours
distances travelled: 48, 66, 96

(C) 11 hours
distances travelled: 44, 60.5, 88

(D) 44 hours
distances travelled: 176, *, *

(E) 200/11 hours
distances travelled: 800/11, *, *

except A) all others have a distance which is not a multiple of 20.
Ans is A)

Himalayan · Answer

oops oops.....

Update: A not D.

sumande · Answer

I think it should be (Distance)/(GCD of the speeds).
Time = (20)/(1/2) = 40 kms.

Andrey2010 · Answer

Hi

This is my solution:

time for every person to make full circle:

20 km / 4 kmh = 5 hours
20 km / 5 kmh = 4 hours
20 km / 0.5 kmh = 10 hours
20 km / 8 kmh = 2.5 hours

We should find LCM for (5, 4, 10, 2.5) but before we have to make them integer (multiple by 2)
LCM (10, 8, 20, 5) = 40

Answer is A.

kevincan · Answer

Keep in mind that there are only three people, who take 4, 40/11 and 5/2 hours to go around once. In h hours, they make h/4, 11h/40 and 2h/5 laps respectively. The number of laps must be an integer in each case, so h has to be a multiple of 4 , 40 and 5. The smallest possible value of h is 40. (A)

oops · Answer

yes, this is an excellent fast approach for this particular problem - the caveat being if there is more than one answer choice that is a multiple of the distance (the least multiple value may not necessarily be correct given other speed combinations).

oops · Answer

kevincan, this is a nice way of figuring it out.
i was familiar with the LCM method (taking the LCM of the time it takes to complete one lap), but was stuck bcoz the LCM of 4, 40/11 and 5/2 wouldn't work in this case. your approach is super!

BTW, what is a quick way to solve the problem if it is not required that they meet at the starting point i.e. find the time it takes for them to all meet the very first time, wherever it be.

GK_Gmat · Answer

Sumande,
Why should it be D/(GCD of Speeds)? Thanks.

GK_Gmat · Answer

20/.5=10 hours???

dahcrap · Answer

Oops I got 200/11. Now I see why it is 40. Good question

oops · Answer

glad you got 200/11 - am happy that somebody thought the same as I did.
but the OA is 40. 
200/11 was not in the answer choices. i added it since that is what i got using the LCM approach (LCM of 4, 40/11 and 5/2 - the time it takes for each of them to complete a lap), which seemed to me as the right approach (and works for most other similar problems).

however, i later realized 200/11 is not the LCM of 4, 40/11 and 5/2 and I made an error in including it. i think now, kevincan's method is correct (although backsolving (finding multiple of 20) is another much easier method, it cannot be used in the general case).

finally, the real challenging part is a variation of this question - i.e. a good method to find when they meet (for the first time) at whatever point on the track (i.e. if NOT specified that they meet at the starting point). the above solutions will not work for this case. i tried to do it using pairwise LCM method, but took way too much time. if anyone has some insight into that, plz explain.

Jane, Chen and Boris start together to travel the same way

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards