From GMATClub v04: Feng Shui, the ancient Chinese art of

Question

From GMATClub v04:

Which of the following best describes the author’s tone in the passage?

(A) Both supportive and critical
(B) Alternately warm and sarcastic
(C) Wavering between disagreement and support
(D) Neither satisfied nor dissatisfied
(E) Variously shocked and proud

I disagree with the OA:

OA is B. Please show me a single example of sarcasm in this article. I think A is a better answer. The author is supportive of the Chinese version of Feng Shui, and critical of the Americanized one. Although you could also say the author is warm towards Chinese Feng Shui, s/he is never sarcastic in describing the Amercanized version.

USCTrojan2006 · Answer

You and me both.

I got A as well. I don't read sarcasm from his statements about the American Practice of Feng Shui. He seems more critical of the American approach to Feng Shui, when compared to the Chinese approach.

The flow of the passage is neither warm, nor sarcastic, but rather informative.

sleekmover · Answer

I got A as well instantaneously. However on second look B makes more sense as there is fundamental problem with A.
A says both. This means at the Same time author is supportive and critical. This will be difficult for many situations leave aside this passage specifically. He is supportive for one and critical for the other not both together for each

B. This treads on a fine line between definition of words . Warm and sarcastic compared to critical and supportive. Howeve it wins bcos it gets it's fundamenTal correct, which is "alternate between". Yes, the author does alternate between being warm and sarcastic (debatable: maybe GMAT club test makers can throw some more light?$

Posted from my mobile device

mariyea · Answer

I'm with you guys on this one. The author is critical in his use of words instead of sarcastic - "American popularized versions of Feng Shui, by contrast, show hardly any concern for directional alignment or key objects, preferring instead the excessive use of crystals, mirrors, and table-top water features, which, though perhaps entertaining, display precious little respect for the real influence of Chi."

:shock:

Or could it be this area of the article that is sarcastic - "when decorators heavily influenced by New Age sensibilities began selling Feng Shui to their clients as a chance to increase health and wealth"?

Where is the question from btw? :roll:

Or could it be this area of the article that is sarcastic - "when decorators heavily influenced by New Age sensibilities began selling Feng Shui to their clients as a chance to increase health and wealth"? Where is the question from btw? :roll:

krishireddy · Answer

The last line of the passage shows that the author is sarcastic abt the passage..."display precious little respect for the real influence of Chi" Precious little respect... :roll:

TehJay · Answer

That's not sarcastic, it's straightforward criticism.

vinzycoolfire · Answer

i too agree with u guys....how are we to detect sarcasm when there is no hint of one :wall

.......

VerbalBot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club VerbalBot: 

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

 This post was generated automatically.

From GMATClub v04: Feng Shui, the ancient Chinese art of

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards