|
|
GMAT Club Daily Prep
Thank you for using the timer - this advanced tool can estimate your performance and suggest more practice questions. We have subscribed you to Daily Prep Questions via email.
Customized
for You
Track
Your Progress
Practice
Pays
Not interested in getting valuable practice questions and articles delivered to your email? No problem, unsubscribe here.
09 Nov 2023, 02:30
Kudos
Bookmarks
C
Be sure to select an answer first to save it in the Error Log before revealing the correct answer (OA)!
Difficulty:
45%
(medium)
Question Stats:
68% (01:51) correct
32%
(02:06)
wrong
based on 455
sessions
History
Date
Time
Result
Not Attempted Yet
A high school has found that, for each of the last 15 years, the average grade point average for members of the cross-country running teams has exceeded the average grade point average for the school as a whole. This phenomenon can most likely be attributed to the fact that long distance runners have so much time to think while running that they can essentially study as they run.
Which of the following most undermines the conclusion drawn above?
A. Cross-country running is more strategic than many realize, requiring runners to expend mental energy thinking about race tactics.
B. Many cross-country runners are also members of the track-and-field team, for which the average grade point average is actually lower than that of the school as a whole.
C. The cross-country team is among the few teams that do not require a try-out, making it a popular activity for high-achieving students who want to list a sport on their college applications.
D. Because the nearest cross-country trails are a long distance from the school, cross-country is one of the most time-consuming activities the school offers.
E. The cross country team's average grade point average has dropped each of the last three years.
Which of the following most undermines the conclusion drawn above?
A. Cross-country running is more strategic than many realize, requiring runners to expend mental energy thinking about race tactics.
B. Many cross-country runners are also members of the track-and-field team, for which the average grade point average is actually lower than that of the school as a whole.
C. The cross-country team is among the few teams that do not require a try-out, making it a popular activity for high-achieving students who want to list a sport on their college applications.
D. Because the nearest cross-country trails are a long distance from the school, cross-country is one of the most time-consuming activities the school offers.
E. The cross country team's average grade point average has dropped each of the last three years.
09 Nov 2023, 03:00
Kudos
Bookmarks
Option C.
If cross-country is among the few teams that do not require a try-out, it might attract high-achieving students looking to bolster their college applications. This could mean that the team has a pool of academically inclined students, potentially explaining the higher average GPA.
If cross-country is among the few teams that do not require a try-out, it might attract high-achieving students looking to bolster their college applications. This could mean that the team has a pool of academically inclined students, potentially explaining the higher average GPA.
02 Dec 2023, 12:45
Kudos
Bookmarks
Bunuel
VERITAS PREP OFFICIAL SOLUTION:
This weaken problem features a common gap in logic: a fact is given (the cross-country GPA is higher than the average GPA) and then one plausible explanation is given as the only explanation for why that fact is true. This is essentially mixing correlation for causation: because two things occur together (runners have a lot of time to think, and runners have high GPAs, the time to think must cause the GPA). The best ways to weaken one of these arguments are to find an alternate explanation or to show that the causation is reversed (it's not that time spent running causes the high GPA, but rather the high GPA leads people to run).
And choice C does exactly that - it suggests that students with high GPAs are more likely to join the cross-country team. It's not that the running makes them better students, but instead good students tend to go toward running as a way to add an extracurricular activity to their application profile. That's why choice C is correct.
Among the wrong choices:
Choice A should be tempting, but it does not directly attack the notion that runners have a lot of time to think. An activity can be strategic and still allow time to think. Choices B, D, and E each try to attack the premise, making you think that the GPA shouldn't be as high as it is. B does this by grouping cross-country runners with the other track-and-field athletes, for whom the GPA is lower. But we already know that the cross-country GPA is high, so it doesn't matter which other groups you could pool them with to lower their grades. Choice D similarly tries to provide a reason why you wouldn't think that the GPA would be high (it's such a time-consuming activity!) but again that doesn't matter - the GPA is high, so we're just trying to determine the cause. And choice E tries to do this by showing that the GPA is dropping, but again it's already been established that it's higher than average, and your only job is to determine why.
