sumruethee
Although I chose A, I was also confused by D. Is D incorrect because the first boldface can’t be a ‘consideration’?
sumruethee Let me clear up your confusion about why D is incorrect.
Your Specific Question: No, D is NOT incorrect because the first boldface can't be a "consideration." Actually, the first boldface
can accurately be called a consideration. An objection or concern is indeed a type of consideration (specifically, a consideration that weighs against something). So the terminology in D is perfectly valid for the first boldface.
The Real Reason D is Incorrect:
The key difference between A and D lies in how they describe the
relationship between the two boldfaced portions:
Choice A: Says the second boldface "weakens the force of that objection"
Choice D: Says the second boldface "supports the plan"
Notice the critical difference:
- A explicitly describes how the second boldface relates to the first boldface
- D merely says the second supports the plan, without specifying its relationship to the first
Why This Matters:
Look at the argument structure:
- Critics raise concern: existing customers will be frustrated and reduce loyalty (First boldface)
- "Nevertheless, the change is unlikely to reduce overall customer retention"
- Why? Because new customers will be attracted (Second boldface)
The word "Nevertheless" and the overall flow show that the second boldface is specifically presented as a
counter to the first concern. It's not just randomly supporting the plan—it's directly addressing and weakening the objection about customer loss.
Strategic Tip for Boldface Questions: Always look for answer choices that capture the
specific relationship between the boldfaced portions, not just their individual roles. The GMAT rewards precision in describing these relationships.
Quick Check Method: Ask yourself: "Does this answer explain how the two portions interact with each other?" Choice A does (second weakens first), while Choice D treats them as independent statements.
Your reasoning was sound—you just got hung up on the wrong detail. Trust your instincts when you correctly identify the logical relationships!