allenmaxin
The original sentence is " Recently the Stasist position is not entirely discounted by new research."
I am very confused about the meaning of "not entirely discounted." If I rewrite the sentence into "Recently the Stasist position is discounted by new research", does the rewritten version still lay in the scope of the original meaning?
One of my friends does not think it is correct because in the rewritten version "discounted" means "completely discounted", which explicitly contradicts the original meaning of the sentence.
But from my point of view, the rewritten version does make sense. It lays in the scope of the original meaning, simply stating a fact that the Stasist position is ever discounted regardless of the extent to which it is discounted.
So is "not entirely discounted" > "discounted" or "discounted" > "not entirely discounted"?
Please give me some advice. Thank you!
First, the original sentence is grammatically incorrect. 'is' is in the present tense. However, 'recently' implies that we're talking about something that happened in the recent past. The correct version would probably use the present perfect tense. This tense is used for things that started or happened in the past, and don't have a clear end point. (If something has been discredited, it hasn't
stopped being discredited, so this tense is appropriate here.)
Recently, the Stasist position has not been entirely discounted by new research.
Second, this is an unusual use of the word 'discount'. Usually, if you use 'discount' in this sense, you'd refer to a person's own evaluation of research, like this:
"I discounted the research due to its poor methodology."
You wouldn't really say that the research has been 'discounted by its poor methodology.' It's possible, but 'discredited' would be more appropriate.
The GMAT doesn't directly test vocabulary, but I'm bringing up this point because it makes me think that this probably isn't a very well-written problem.As for your question, if something is
not entirely discredited, that usually means that it's been a
little discredited, but not
completely discredited.
Compare it to these sentences:
Her shirt is not purple. = it could be any color, as long as it isn't purple.
Her shirt is not entirely purple. = it probably has
some purple on it (although it might not, depending on the context), but it isn't 100% purple.