Beth has a collection of 8 boxes of clothing for a charity, and the

That's the way to go about on this one, yessir!

Hi there!
Thank you for your answer.

If I may ask you how you canceled (8c+10)/8 and got c+5/4? Would you please explain?
Thank you!

michaelkalend , because the answer is a year old and because original poster might have unfollowed this topic, I will answer.

Sometimes it's the little things we miss.

14101992 split the numerator to simplify, thus:

\(\frac{(8c + 10)}{8}\)

= \(\frac{8c}{8}\) + \(\frac{10}{8}\)

Factor out 8 in the first term. That leaves c

Simplify second term, \(\frac{10}{8}\) = \(\frac{5}{4}\)

And you have c + \(\frac{5}{4}\)

Hope that helps.

Seems so easy! Thank you very much!

hi pushpitkc generis,

my "approach" to this problem was similar to that of a cancer - sideways and not straightforward perhaps thats why i missed something

let total number of clothing be \(x\), now since one box containing \(12\) pieces was replaced by bigger box containing \(22\)--> \(22-12 =10\)

so number of boxes did not change. so we have \(\frac{x+10}{8} =c\) ---> \(\frac{x+5}{4} =c\) this is actually the new average number isnt it ?

so what`s my next step ? i did this \(x+5=4c\) now what ?

dave13 , fairly close. Conceptual error:
No, that last equation is not the new average.
Sum 2 = x + 10
\(n\) has not changed. You are correct.

Careful: (x+10) is after ADDING to original total

You're working in reverse. To get to original average \(c\), SUBTRACT what got added.

Then you could say instead (use MINUS 10)

(New SUM 2 = x) - (added #), divided by 8, equals old average, thus:
\(\frac{x-10}{8}=c\)
This logic gets a little confusing. Split the LHS numerators:

\(\frac{x}{8}-\frac{10}{8}=c\)

\(\frac{x}{8}=c+\frac{10}{8}\)

\(\frac{x}{8}=c+\frac{5}{4}\)

\(x\)= Sum 2
\(8 = n\)
So \(\frac{Sum_2}{n}=A_{new}\)
AND thus \(\frac{x}{8}=A_{new}=c+\frac{5}{4}\)

That works. You needed subtraction instead of addition on LHS. This approach is hard, but you were close. That state of affairs indicates that you mostly or entirely understand the concepts.

This approach is hard in part because it includes another variable that is not needed. But if you like the method, so be it!

Another approach without \(x\)? Let's use
A, Average (# of items per box)
n, number of boxes
S, Sum (total items)
\(A*n=S\) and hence \(A=\frac{Sum}{n}\)

Stage 1
\(A*n=Sum_1\)
\(A=c\)
\(n=8\)
\(Sum_1=?\)

Interim: \(Sum_1\) changes.
12 are removed (-12) and 20 are added (+20). That process = \(Sum_2\) at Stage 2

Stage 2
\(A_2= ?\)
\(n=8\)
\(Sum_2\): (Stage 1 Sum) - 12 + 20 = ?

We want new average. Use rearranged formula. If \(A*n=Sum\), then \(A=\frac{Sum}{n}\)

\(A_2=\frac{Sum_2}{n}\)

See whether that works for you?

The sum of Beth’s original boxes is 8c.

After she replaces a 12-piece box with a 22-piece box, the new sum is 8c - 12 + 22 = 8c + 10, so the new average is:

(8c + 10)/8 = 8c/8 + 10/8 = c + 5/4

Answer: B

The average can also be thought of as the value each input takes IF all of the inputs are equal. For example, the average of 6,7,8 is 7. because 6+7+8=7+7+7...

Now 10 more pieces of clothing get added. These need to be distributed evenly. 10/8=5/4

Since each box averaged c pieces of clothing before, each box now averages c+5/4 pieces of clothing.

Please verify if my method is sound

We can use Test It. Let's say C = 10

That means 10 = (SUM)/8

SUM = 80

Now if one of the boxes were replaced with a box that has 22 pieces of clothing, the new SUM will be 80 + (22-12) = 90
The new value of C should be 90/8 = 11.25

Now plug in 10 in each of the answer choices to see which answer gives 11.25.

A) c- \(\frac{5}{4}\)

10- \(\frac{5}{4}\) = Does not equal 11.25

B) c+ \(\frac{5}{4}\)

10 + \(\frac{5}{4}\) = 11.25 (MATCH)

C) 8- \(\frac{10}{c}\)

8- \(\frac{10}{10}\) = 7 No Match

D) 8+\(\frac{10}{c}\)

8+\(\frac{10}{10}\) = 9 NO match

E) 8c-10 Wayy to big!

let each box have 12 - c=12

if one is replaced by 22 -

22-12 =10 extra and this is divided by 8

this is 5/4

Hello from the GMAT Club BumpBot!

Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up - doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos).

Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.