Last visit was: 19 Nov 2025, 15:07 It is currently 19 Nov 2025, 15:07
Share
User avatar
3 years
India
2024
Male
Score: 740 GMAT Classic
GPA: 4
Pre-MBA industry: Other
Post-MBA industry: Other
ISB
Full Time MBA
Full Time MBA
Round 1, 2024
InterviewedOct 21, 23
AcceptedNov 17, 23
ScholarshipNone
1 year ago
13 Sep 2024 03:09
Booth
Full Time MBA
Full Time MBA
Round 1, 2024
DeniedOct 14, 23
2 years ago
30 Oct 2023 11:10
Fuqua
Full Time MBA
Full Time MBA
Round 1, 2024
DeniedOct 26, 23
2 years ago
30 Oct 2023 11:10
LBS
Full Time MBA
Full Time MBA
Round 1, 2024
DeniedOct 12, 23
2 years ago
30 Oct 2023 11:10
Johnson (Cornell)
Full Time MBA
Full Time MBA
Round 1, 2024
AppliedSep 18, 23
2 years ago
30 Oct 2023 11:10
Tuck
Full Time MBA
Full Time MBA
Round 1, 2024
AppliedSep 18, 23
2 years ago
30 Oct 2023 11:10
2 years ago
30 Oct 2023 11:10
I come from a very over-represented background - an Indian Male Engineer.


Current role
I work as an Engineer for a small family-run business in the UAE. We are one of the largest suppliers of aftermarket Marine and Power Plant diesel engine parts. Though It would be difficult to categorize my role in a single category, I believe that Product management most resembles the work that I do. I am responsible for all Technical and Commercial decisions for an Engine segment. This being a small company, one has to handle other aspects like marketing and sales to a certain extent.

Short Term Goals
I feel that restricting myself to a very technical and niche industry, such as the one I am currently in, might hamper my future career prospects. Lately, I have been finding it difficult to switch to Product roles in big companies.

Immediately after an MBA, I plan to take up a Product management role at a Fintech company.

Currently application status

I am primarily targeting schools in the US and have applied to 6 schools in Round 1. I have been rejected by 3 schools (Booth, LBS, Duke) and have not heard back from the other 2 (Tuck, Cornell). With the initial decision date approaching fast, my chances of getting an interview invite from Cornell and Tuck seem relatively slim.

Considering my experience handicap, does it make sense to apply to other B-schools in Round 2? If yes, which ones should I apply to? I do not want to waste another year.
Comments 5 comments
User avatar
2 years ago
30 Oct 2023, 12:01
Sorry about the dings. I would consider Darden as well. I would also get the profile in-depth evaluation from a consultant or a friend who is a student to see if perhaps you have some thing very obvious that can be fixed quickly…
User avatar
2 years ago
31 Oct 2023, 10:53
Hi bb,
Thanks for replying. I have worked with a consultant for all of these applications. He says that my experience is on the lower side and that I should apply next year.

I would take your advice and apply for Darden in Round 2.
User avatar
2 years ago
31 Oct 2023, 13:10
Did you consultant tell you that your experiences on the lower side before you applied or after you got the dings? 😬
User avatar
2 years ago
31 Oct 2023, 13:14
Do you have 3 years of work experience right now or at matriculation?
User avatar
2 years ago
01 Nov 2023, 06:38
Hi Advitya,

My first thought is about the career goal- why PM in fintech? You don't have any relevant experience in Fintech as such, so why have such a specific career goal? Another reason I would ask this is that do your target companies ( as stated in the goals ) visit the b-schools where you applied?
The second question is (as Bb asked) - will your experience be 3 yrs at matriculation? If yes, it would be on the lower side and can pose a hindrance. This is where another factor also kicks in- what is your profile outside of work? are you involved in ECAs? Volunteering/ CSR/ community initiatives? Presenting a well rounded profile is helpful at the top b-schools. LBS, for example, has an essay on extra curricular activities, and Booth has an essay on your personality outside work. So, having a well rounded profile can go a long way in coming up with good essay content.
If it helps, I can have a look at one of your applications (gratis) and give you broad advice on any improvement areas. Should you be interested you can write to me at contact@mbadecoder.com
That may help you decide if R2 makes sense.
Namita, MBA Decoder.com