Failures and ethical dilemmas

Question

I really didn't face many, at least any worth talking about. I mean that's a whole point of avoiding these if you want to keep the job.

If I get asked that during interview, I might have a hiccup.

What did you guys cook up for your answers? 

I understand that the failure itself isn't important as much as the way you handled it, but let's say I tell them that I didn't complete some important work assignment on time and let's say since then I keep a calendar and I am much more organized and never missed another deadline again. Would that fly?

For ethical it's even tougher, cause you need to have one damn good reason why something you did might appear unethical.

pelihu · Answer

I think that these types of questions reflect the level of responsibility and involvement a candidate has had. I agree that the important point is what you learned and how you've grown.

One example I used was when I worked as a volunteer helping immigrants facing deportation file for humanitarian relief. Certain laws (drug offenses, violent crimes, etc.) trigger automatic deportation provisions. Some people face deportation to countries with severe human rights issues. We assisted people by handling final appeals based on humanitarian concerns over deportation to certain countries. The ethical dilemma was that these people had been convicted serious crimes - things like armed robbery and kidnapping - but my job was to support their causes based on humanitarian concerns.

I learned that, because of worldwide economic disparity, people from around the world preferred to serve long prison sentences rather than be returned to their home countries where they faced famine, war, mutilation and death. I said that my experience led me to realize that, more than almost any political or social movement, worldwide economic development might result in the greatest possible good for the greatest number of people; and that I was inspired to help develop growing economies for the benefit of local populations.

lepium · Answer

Try the positive way out, eg: "I came up with this brilliant idea of how to save 10% costs but pitched it miserably and it was never implemented."

So, it's not the kind of failure that would leave you without a job. 
And, it's the kind of failure where you can learn something (how to pitch ideas better)

Hope it helps. L.

johnnyx9 · Answer

I think Pelihu just gave the best answer one could possibly give. Mind if I use that? (kidding)

I've totally struggled with the "ethical" sort of interview questions too, I just can't come up with anything good. I've never really had my ethics challenged in any situation that would work well for an interview answer. I guess I could tell them about how back in high school I knew drinking was illegal for people under 21, but I did a risk-utility analysis and decided I would go ahead and break the law anyway, going against my high ethical standards. And then after I tell them that I'll say, "So? Am I in or what?"

amorica · Answer

how about this one?....

You will probably notice a couple of descrepencies between my transcript and my application. The truth is, I did not attend Harvard. In fact, I never graduated from college. I lied on my resume and applicaiton.

Ultimately though, I learned from this mistake. I know that it is important to be truthful and to maintian a high level of integrity. This is the exact integrity I will show if admitted.

pelihu · Answer

I look at ethical dilemmas and setbacks/failures as separate issues.

I believe the point of asking about a setback or failure is to gauge the maturity of the candidate. Nobody likes to talk about their own failures, but an effective manager needs to be mature enough to admit mistakes, analyze and move on. To a greater or lesser extent, everyone has had setbacks and failures; the question is are you "man enough" (ladies included) to talk about them.

An ethical dilemma is a different type of problem. I think it is a way to try to find out what makes a candidate tick. A lot can be learned based on the type of experience that the person selects. For one person, it might be an ethical dilemma whether or not to take money from a petter cash drawer. This would show a very different person than someone that struggles about turning in their boss for securities violations. It's not just a difference in the level of responsibility; it's actually a difference in the perceived characters of the two individuals, based on their values.

As suggested in essay-writing books, it's probably a mistake to select a situation that isn't really a dilemma or setback. It's like someone that says their greatest flaw is that they work too hard. Give me a break. Adcoms are going to think you are a pompous moron if you say something like that. A dilemma is a situation where both sides have merit (or risks) and it is truly a challenge to decide between them. A setback or failure should be self-explanatory, but it shouldn't be about a situation where you actually succeeded. Don't say, "I had a setback because our deal earned 100%, while I always shoot to earn 110%. It's a failure for me to do less." People will think you are a jackass.

Nsentra · Answer

thanks for the break down pelihu.

johnnyx9 · Answer

If I were in the ad-com position I would definitely ask these questions because as Pelihu said, they tell you a lot about the person.

The thing is, I really cannot think of a single real ethical dilemma that I have faced. Maybe that means I've had a really boring life, but at the end of the day it means that I'm going to have to make something up. Hopefully they don't notice that I'm crossing my fingers when I'm answering their question.

MBAbot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club MBAbot: 

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

 This post was generated automatically.

Failures and ethical dilemmas

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards