Quote:
During the performance, a challenging work by an artist
whose devotees say has become more open than ever to meta-reflection and revision, Abramović reconnected with Ulay, the former longtime partner she had until then not seen in decades.
A. whose devotees say has become more open than ever to meta-reflection and revision, Abramović reconnected
B. who devotees say she has become ever more open to meta-reflection and revision, Abramović reconnected
C. whose devotees say she has become more than ever open to meta-reflection and revision, Abramović reconnects
D. who devotees say has become ever more open to meta-reflection and revision, Abramović reconnected
E. who devotees say becomes more open than ever to meta-reflection and revision, Abramović is reconnecting
Veritas Prep Explanation:
The correct answer is D.This answer correctly uses the subject form pronoun “who” as the subject of “has become” and the past tense “reconnected” to fit the timeline of “she had until then”; “ever more open” is an acceptable idiomatic construction to describe Abramović’s growing openness.
Answer A uses the possessive relative pronoun “whose” incorrectly. As a possessive, “whose” functions as an adjective. For this reason, “whose” cannot be the subject of any verb, including the verb “has become” in this sentence. So what, exactly, is the subject of “has become”? A verb inside a modifier must take its subject within that same modifier, but neither “whose” nor “devotees” can logically and grammatically function as the subject of “has become.” As such, this answer has a sentence construction error.
Answer B creates the opposite error; both “who” and “she” fight to act as the subject of “has become,” and the result is another sentence construction error.
Answer C, though awkward-sounding, technically is correct in saying “whose devotees say she has become.” However, this answer mangles the verb tense at the end. The past tense “reconnected” is required to fit the timeline of “she had until then” from later in the sentence. This latter phrase makes clear that the performance and the reconnection must have both taken place in the past.
Answer E again mangles the verb tenses. The use of “becomes” suggests a general truism rather than a specific action. This is at best a bit odd, but perhaps it is survivable. However, the later “is reconnecting” cannot work at all. The past tense “reconnected” is required to fit the timeline of “she had until then” from later in the sentence. This latter phrase makes clear that the performance and the reconnection must have both taken place in the past.